Nicholas Carr's Argument That Google Is Making USupid

Nicholas Carr is well known American writer who has written article and books based on business, technology and culture. In 2011, he was the finalist for Pulitzer Prize in General Notification for his book The Shallows: What The Internet Is Doing To Our Brains.In Nicholas Carr’s article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, he wrote for The Atlantic on Jul 1, 2008. It's very plausible, complicated and persuasive article. The article makes many believable connections to every day's life, compelling people by using metaphors, staying true to the point and using different rhetorical approaches.

When assessing the risks of digital technology’s role in our future, many reflect on the developments of new technology throughout history. Nicholas Carr, author of “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” uses historical examples to support his claim that we should fear technological advancements. In contrast, Brooke Gladstone and Josh Neufeld, authors of “The Influencing Machines,” examine both sides of the issue and ultimately conclude that we should not fear technological development. One technological development Carr as well as Gladstone and Neufeld examined was the printing press. Carr asserts that most of the arguments about the printing press turned out to be correct including that it “would undermine religious authority, demean the work of scholars

In Nicholas Carr (Is Google Making Us Stupid?) he expresses his thoughts of the internet, and how it is effecting our minds. He goes in on how it becomes hard to comprehend long articles and books. It seems as if our brains start to become unfocused as we try not to skim the words; yet, or brains do as they please causing us to become distracted from the writings in front of us.

Carr believes the vast amount of time he spends surfing the web and researching is to blame for this. I agree with Carr, I often find it hard to read books, articles, and essays that I'm required to for school. Google is making us stupid.

In Nicholas Carr’s article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, he shows us how and why technology is changing people’s brain and the way they think. Carr establishes credibility by giving examples from professors knowledge. He uses different maxims such as quantity and relevance to show is points. With each of these maxims he paints a good picture about the struggles of how technology is making people become less capable of retaining information. He even goes on to describe how the neurons can rewire themselves to have a different function. Each of his examples go on to further prove that google is in fact making us stupid.

Throughout his article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, Nicholas Carr uses several terms and phrases that enhance his argument. One key term that is central to Carr’s argument is the word “reprogramming”. Carr uses this word several times throughout his article to assert his claim that the Internet is “reprogramming” or changing our minds in a way that alters our thinking and memory. By using this term, it seems that Carr adds gravity to the possibility that the Internet is changing our minds for the worst. Likewise, Carr mentions that the Internet is interfering with our “concentration” and causing it to “drift” from certain activities such as deep reading. He argues that our brain is scattering with frequent use of the Internet. It is hard

In, “Is Google Really Making Us Stupid?” by Nicholas Carr (2008), he validates how people are heavily relying on the internet pushing for Artificial Intelligence. Carr also talks about how it is changing the way our minds work with negative side effects. He demonstrates how the internet may be shaping our thought process by giving observational examples as well as personal experiences. Beginning with his personal experiences he says how he finds it difficult to keep focused on a book, as a writer, this is rare to him. He tries to find a reason to his inability to stay focused and comes to a conclusion it is due to the internet. Carr is very persuasive in his article, although his point of view maybe seen as an opinion, he does show and support

From beginning to ending, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” written by Nicholas Carr implements a scene from A Space Odyssey, where Bowman disconnects HAL’s circuits as it repeats, “I can feel it. I can feel it” to underscore the notion of humans becoming more robotic than a robot itself as we continue to rely on technology. Carr portrays this notion through several examples when he, his colleagues, and an individual like Friedman experience a shift in their style in writing or reading as they use certain technological tools. These resourceful technologies force individuals to make adaptations to “patterns” that ultimately influence their lifestyles. Carr consistently provides significant amounts of evidence for his argument and in depth information

The essay Is Google Making Us Stupid by the author Nicholas Carr, was originally a cover article of The Atlantic in 2008. The purpose of his work is to warn the technology users of the negative effects that these devices have in humans. Carr starts the essay with a scene from Stanley Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey in which one of the characters describes how his mind and the way he reads is changing by the time since he has been using a computer. He is no longer able to spend hours reading, describes how to get concentrate in a long paragraphs is difficult to him. The fact of how fast the internet works, forces his brain to process information the way Net does.

In my opinion, the invention of the internet, and therefore google/any search engine, has not made us stupid, but rather made us lazy and increased our ability to procrastinate. Before, when students had to conduct research for a paper/assignment, they would have to go to a library

Nicholas Carr’s essay “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” is a piece that will open the eyes of any internet user. He explains his own issues with lack of focus when reading long novels and says it is a product of the interweb’s shaping. As Google becomes more and more part of our daily lives, it is having a negative effect on our information processes and interpretations. In effect, its current use is preventing us from retaining information and to be able to think, comprehend, and be inquisitive.

Nicholas Carr’s “Is Google Making Us Stupid” shows how the use of a computer can truly affect our thought process. Carr’s point of view shows us that he believes that these computers are changing us for the worst. Although I would have to take the opposite position on his work, and feel the internet has changed society for the better. First, the internet has become such an essential piece of technology in schooling. Second, being able to talk to someone over the internet in an entirely different country is a huge advantage; think about how long it could take to send a letter or even inconvenience someone with a phone call. Being able to talk with someone on the

In his essay, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, author Nicholas Carr discusses his belief that the internet is negatively changing the way people’s brains process and consume information. Carr describes this phenomenon when he writes, “as we come to rely on computers to mediate our understanding of the world, it is our own intelligence that flattens into artificial intelligence” (328). Carr’s point is that the less effort put into reading and researching caused by societies constant access to the internet, lessens deep thinking and mental growth, which in turn results in a loss of individualism in our society. Incidentally, in his article, “Smarter than you Think”, writer Clive Thompson agrees with Carr’s statement by saying, “Today’s multitasking tools really do make it harder than before to stay focused during long acts of reading and contemplation” (355). However, Thompson goes on to argue that the benefits humans derive from the advancements being made in technology outweigh the possible risks in changes to cognitive functions caused by the melding of man with machine. Thompson builds his argument by examining how the game of chess has evolved

Is Google making us stupid? Nicholas Carr posed the question via “The Atlantic” in 2008 and received an uproar of feedback. His argument was that the internet might have detrimental effects on cognitive capacity. The article in itself, according to online critics, was targeted more at the World Wide Web than at Google, specifically. Throughout the six page piece, he argued that reading on the internet is a shallower comparison to putting your nose in a book. Since then, the topic has been widely debated.

On Carr's stance on the question, is Google making us stupid, I would be compelled to disagree with him and say that it's actually making us smarter. His idea of saying that we are becoming stupid because of Google is a paradox because we learn so much every day from going to Google and researching something and he's saying that his ability to concentrate is diminishing. Instances that actually enable us to become smarter by using Google would be the way we can instantly find information, because of the internet we are now reading far more than we did in the 1970s, and because of how we read on the internet, we changed our style of reading to a style that puts efficiency and immediacy above everything. We are just adapting to a new type of