preview

O Henry And The Gift Of The Magi

Satisfactory Essays

“Gift of the Magi” by sesame street and “Gift of the Magi” by O.Henry have a variety of similarities and differences. In both sesame streets version and O.Henrys version, the partners trade something special that belongs to themselves, in order to get a great gift for their partner. Another similarity is in both stories the gifts that each partner receives has no use to them. For example, when Ernie receives a cigar box for his paper clip collection, it has no use since Ernie traded his paperclip collection in to afford Bert's gift. A difference between the stories is at the end Mr. Hooper realizes what is happening and decides to give Bert and Ernie's Paperclips and rubber ducky back. In the version by O. Henry, Della and James never get back their possessions that they traded. …show more content…

In both sesame streets version and O.Henrys version, the partners trade something special that belongs to themselves, in order to get a great gift for their partner. Another similarity is in both stories the gifts that each partner receives has no use to them. For example, when Ernie receives a cigar box for his paper clip collection, it has no use since Ernie traded his paperclip collection in to afford Bert's gift. A difference between the stories is at the end Mr. Hooper realizes what is happening and decides to give Bert and Ernie's Paperclips and rubber ducky back. In the version by O. Henry, Della and James never get back their possessions that they traded. The relationships are also different. In Sesame streets version Bert and Ernie are just friends. In O. henrys version they are a married couple.Another difference is the gifts that both partners received. In the sesame street version Bert and Ernie give each other a cigar box and a soap dish. In the version by O. Henry, Della and James get each other more expensive gifts, such as hair combs and a watch

Get Access