preview

On Two Friars

Decent Essays
Open Document

The first chapter of G.K. Chesterton’s biography of Thomas Aquinas, Saint Thomas Aquinas, entitled “On Two Friars”, compares and contrasts the two great friars: Thomas Aquinas and Saint Francis. Chesterton describes just how vastly different these two friars were, while also remarking on how similar they were at the very same time. Thomas was a man of reason and logic, whereas Francis was a man of the wild and nature. Francis’ naturalism led him to the conversion of many non-Christians, as he believed that widespread Christianity is the main focus of the religion, whereas Aquinas, “the dumb ox,” believed that we must first discover Christianity ourselves before spreading it across the earth. Aquinas is described by Chesterton as being a “dunce” …show more content…

Francis used Nature much as St. Thomas used Aristotle; and to some they seemed to be using a Pagan goddess and a Pagan sage,” (Chesterton 29)showing just how different the two ideologies or methods of the two friars are. Due to these differences in ideologies, different eras have taken likings to the two different friars respectively. Chesterton himself describes that, “Therefore it is the paradox of history that each generation is converted by the saint who contradicts it the most,” (Chesterton 24) showing that each and every generation takes a liking to their own respective philosopher. In the case of Assisi and Aquinas, Assisi took hold in the 19th century full of imperialism, and Aquinas has taken hold in the 20th century, wherein we seek reason as we have begun to divulge from reason. This search for a proper philosopher in order to fulfill ones needs is common place for society, wherein we constantly want to grow or change who we are, and ultimately the popularity of philosophers is influenced by their methods. As stated previously, both Aquinas and Assisi used very different and often seemingly heretical ideas of Nature and Aristotle, Chesterton even described them as “Pagan goddess and a Pagan Sage,” (Chesterton 29) showing just how foreign and strange these ideas were to Christians of their

Get Access