preview

Parapsychological Argument

Decent Essays

The purpose of science is to work towards furthering our comprehension of how the world around us works, either by observing certain patterns or collecting empirical evidence with the experimental method. It has been evidenced that “mainstream science” has rejected parapsychology for decades now; textbooks ignore the concept of telekinesis, which is the power to move objects with one’s mind (McGreal, 2014), and science agencies have refused to provide funding for scientific research that studies parapsychology (Alcock, 1987). Although many proponents of parapsychology argue that scientists must consider all “empirical” evidence with an “open-mind” and that the mere existence of evidence indicates psi’s validity as a science (McGreal, 2014), …show more content…

A major principle that the concepts of parapsychology violate is the replicability principle; the main argument made by sceptics is that, because attempts to reliably replicate initially successful psi experiments have had a history of repeated failure, parapsychology is not only unconvincing but also demonstrates an inconsistency that conflicts with the nature of scientific concepts and patterns about the natural world. In addition to lack of reliable evidence, the concepts and ideas of parapsychology have not been substantiated with an entity of scientific knowledge containing a “coherent rationale or framework,” and is merely a collection of “anecdotal evidence” (Holroyd, 1997). Parapsychology also violates the extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence principle; psi is definitely an extraordinary concept, to the point of supernatural, yet there is a very small amount of substantial or significantly consistent evidence that supports this theory, if any at all; in fact, existing evidence has been shown to be inconsistent and contradictory. Finally psi is rejected by the Occam’s Razor principle because of the complexity of its topics and subsequent explanations for its effect, due to the fact that it cannot be supported by any implicit physical or biological

Get Access