preview

Personal Identity From Reasons And Persons

Decent Essays

Rebecca Arruda Student Number November 8th, 2017 Class Name and Number Teachers Name Quantum Identity; A response to Derek Partif’s “Personal Identity from Reasons and Persons” In the famous television show “Star Trek” one of the most recognizable quotes from the original series is when Captain Kirk says “Beam me up Scotty.” He says this in order to be transported back onto the ship from a planet they are on. They do this with the use of the Transporter which is a device to teleport people from the ship onto a target area which converts the subject into energy in a process called “dematerialization” and beamed to the area and reconverted into matter i.e. “rematerialization”. It destroys them and reanimates them but are they the …show more content…

Qualitative is defined by him as the person in essence, personality, thoughts, ideals, and who they are whereas Numerical is defined as the person in form, biology, chemistry, attributes, and what they are. He uses these terms to distinguish the two main aspects of what it means to be “you” or to define who someone “is” simply because no matter how you name these terms every person has these terms unique to themselves (Partif, 559-560). For example, twins would be numerically identical to a certain extent however they would be qualitatively different because despite being numerically identical they are different people with different minds, thoughts, and personalities. An example of two identities that are qualitatively identical and numerically different can be seen in art. In an art context qualitative would be defined as “content” and numerical as “form” thus two paintings could look completely different formally, or numerically but have the same meaning, content, or qualitative definition. Later in this section Partif asks the questions mentioned earlier and proceeds to answer the second, third, and partially the first. He does this with the answer “X today is one and the same person as Y at some past time if and only if…”(Partif, 560) which basically means that the same person today is the same person x time ago if the past person meets certain conditions. However, this answer is vague because it can only go one

Get Access