preview

Phar Mor Fraud Case

Decent Essays

Phar-Mor, a discount drug store chain, was established in 1982. They would offer medications at a 25-40% discount rate by buying in bulk and reselling. By 1987, there were almost 100 stores in business. In 1988, there was an investigation of lower than expected profit margins which revealed a billing type scheme involving un-received inventory. Tamco, its sister company, would bill Phar-Mor for inventory that was never received which led to costing Phar-Mor $7,000,000 and therefore reporting a $2,000,000 profit that year. Another problem Phar-Mor was facing was following of the formation of the World Basketball League (WBL) which Monus owned 60% of the league. In order to cover up $7000 a night loss, Monus would embezzle a total $15,000,000 …show more content…

Monus, was found guilty of embezzling more than $10,000,00 and was sentenced to 19 years in prison. 1. Could SOX have prevented the Phar-Mor fraud? How? Which specific sections of SOX? Considering the elaborateness of the Phar-Mor fraud, I don’t think it would have been completely prevented, but I do believed that had SOX been implemented at the time, the fraud would have been uncovered much sooner than the decade it took. By applying Title II, Section 203, “audit partner rotation” a registered public account firm may not provide an audit if the lead audit partner has performed audit services in each of the five previous fiscal years. Section 206 states that any auditor who had previously worked for the firm and now works for Phar-Mor would make it a conflict of interest and therefore, unlawful for the firm to perform any audit service. Phar-more had 3 employees who were previously employed by Coopers, the audit firm. Section 404 requires that internal controls be assessed and tested once per fiscal year which would have helped uncover the fraud much sooner since the auditors would have been required to check over the inventory

Get Access