preview

Philip J. Deloria's Indians In Unexpected Places

Decent Essays

In his book Indians in Unexpected Places, Philip J. Deloria discusses the Native American anomaly and how expectations are interweaved into the concept of what defines an anomaly. He describes Indian anomalies with a mostly negative connotation with the intent of allowing people to look deeper into what they perceive as Native American anomalies instead of perpetuating them. In this way, such ideas about anomalies, as they are tied to ideas linked with racist discourses, cannot be broken until they are separated from expectations. Deloria calls for thinking about why anomalies are perpetuated instead of simply accepting them as they are. Deloria explains that “the naming of an anomaly simultaneously re-creates and empowers the very same categories that it escapes” (Deloria, 5). Within the medium of film, especially Westerns, people might automatically deem Native Americans as types of anomalies if they do not fit certain expectations of what people already think about Native Americans. The character Martin Pawley in John Ford’s film The Searchers could be considered an anomaly without further examination. However, in this case, Martin’s character has the potential to be considered in a more positive …show more content…

Martin is very attached to his White adopted family, and he also hesitates to act violently or brutally towards Native Americans, despite the influence of Ethan Edwards, who consistently demonstrated his hatred for and violent tendencies toward Native Americans. Director John Ford concluded the film by showing Martin joining a family, while Ethan leaves by himself. In this way, Martin’s character leaves behind any trace of either White or Native American stereotypes or expectations, despite being ethnically defined as

Get Access