preview

Phyllida Brown's Article Summary

Decent Essays

In the article, “Is Drinking Alcohol While Pregnant an Unnecessary Risk to Prenatal Development,” Phyllida Brown believes that drinking is bad for pregnant women and can put the baby at risk for Fetus Alcohol Syndrome (FAS) (76). She supports her claim by providing follow-ups on children whose mother consumed alcohol during pregnancy. The children whose mother consumed alcohol, tend to be more aggressive and had a hard time focusing compared to children whose mother didn’t consume alcohol. Some physical traits that children with FAS have are thin lips and tend to be smaller than the average kid (Brown 76). Brown also supports her argument by using a counterargument about how some women claims that it is okay to drink wine or alcohol every once …show more content…

But what I find to be interesting is that fact that although Moskin and some other women believe that it is okay to consumed alcohol during pregnancy; they only drink about a maximum of one to three drinks a week only (81). I believe that what Moskin and other women wanted to say was that it is okay for a pregnant woman to drink. However, there are consequences if you drink more than two or three drinks a week. The reason I believe so is because if they strongly believe that it is okay for a pregnant woman to drink, then they would of drank more than three drinks and wouldn’t care about how much drinks they had. But overall, I think Moskin provided enough evidence to support her argument although it seemed like she was contradicting herself a …show more content…

Not being able to perform clinical trials on pregnant women might complicate the effort to understand the effects of alcohol on prenatal development because we really don’t know if the tests that are performed on animals are really accurate with human beings. For example, Moskin even stated it herself that two drinks on a laboratory mouse might be different on a woman due to their size and functionality. As for funding and time, it’s going to take a lot of money and time to run tests on children whose mothers were exposed to alcohol and on the children whose mothers weren’t exposed to alcohol. And if researchers do want to dig in deeper in prenatal development, then they will have to keep in mind that some physical traits that children with FAS have may come from their parent’s genes, and not from the alcohol. Therefore, they will have to conduct more studies and find more participants to understand the effects of alcohol on prenatal

Get Access