preview

Planned Parenthood Case Summary

Good Essays

PORTLAND, Oregon- “I was terrified,” plaintiff Dr. Warren Martin Hern stated as he heard he was on the “Deadly Dozen, GUILTY” poster. The first amendment has been strained throughout this case for the reasons of the unknown. The major question in the Planned Parenthood of the Columbia/Willamette, Inc. v. ACLA case is “what defines a true threat?” Plaintiff, planned parenthood, sued the American coalition of Life Activist under the FACE act because planned parenthood felt that ACLA was targeting them with WANTED and unWANTED posters that included all of the physicians’ personal information. There were four major abortion physicians that also became the plaintiffs in the first trial. Those physicians consisted of Dr. Robert Crist, Dr. Warren …show more content…

Gunn was shot and killed as he was walking into the clinic. Two other murders happened before Planned Parenthood said anything about suing. The FBI adviced all doctors that perform abortion to take precautions and wear bullet proof vest. The FBI also offered protection for the doctors and their families if they felt like that is what they needed. The Guilty posters than were announced and thirteen doctors were named on the poster as well as all of their personal information. The trial all started when Planned Parenthood had enough of ACLA’s …show more content…

And it’s clear the pro-life people, traditionally, I believe, call abortion providers abortionists. So, there should not be any adverse reaction to these people using the lingo and terminology of their protest,” the court states. The First amendment does protect speech but the ACLA knew what their posters were doing and the proceeded to make them. That is why ACLA is guilty. “Do what we tell you to do, or we will kill you,” is how Dr. Hern interpreted the Deadly Dozen list poster that was announced on January 25,1995. Hern was one of the many doctors listed on the poster, but he was not the only one terrified. Advocates for Life Ministries

Get Access