Poe And Doyle's Controversy

Usually, fairy tales are in connection to big and illustrious happy endings. But in Edgar Allan Poe’s case, it is evident that they do not exist, for his stories more often than not bear a grotesque demeanor. His life was surrounded by death. All of the women in his life died young, including his mother, sister, and wife. By the age of three, he had experienced what most would not experience until nearly the middle or end of their lives. Living in such an atmosphere allowed Poe to reach deep into his emotions when writing. Edgar Allan Poe was known for his macabre metaphors. These metaphors challenged the reader to endeavor themselves into his simple words; coming to find the gothic elements portrayed. He most commonly portrayed love and death in his poems. Poe is even credited with contributing to the emerging genre of science fiction. Edgar Allan Poe utilizes symbolism and portrays an envious love tale, ending in tragedy to expose the speaker’s emotional state in the poem “Annabel Lee.”

The law enforcers are confused because they cannot identify how the criminal escaped. They declare the murders unsolvable; however, C. Auguste Dupin, a man who loves mysteries, steps into the scene to attempt to untangle the puzzle. While he is looking for clues to solve the mystery, the spectators and citizens provide insight into the story as well, setting the context and atmosphere that Poe wishes to narrate the story with. At last, after Dupin find clues that lead to a possible victim, including a fingerprint and a window that could be opened and closed from the outside, he deduces that the murderer was an orangutan. After the orangutan is convicted, the story slows down quickly, leading to the selling of the orangutan by the sailor who owned him and the increasing of the confidence that Dupin has in himself. “The Murders in the Rue Morgue” is a strange short story because of its irregularity in characters. Not only does Poe make an orangutan the murderer in the story, he describes the peculiar attributes and characteristics that the policemen and the townspeople possess. Through the peculiar characters that he establishes in the short story, Poe gives an example of the American Dream. Dupin was a man who had fallen into poverty and destitution; however, by taking on the mystery and working diligently to solve a case that had been deemed as unsolvable, Dupin shows that redemption can be achieved through determination and confidence.

When you think about the first detective story ever written, Edgar Allen Poe probably doesn’t come to mind. He is most known for his melancholic and gruesome tales of stories such as a guilty man’s conscience giving him the impression of hearing the man he killed heart beating through the floorboards, or even a raven symbolizing the inevitable death we will all face. Despite these well-known contributions, his writings concerning the detective field have left an indisputable mark on pieces following his time.

Poe and “The Cask of Amontillado” were interlocked in many ways, but Poe wanting comeuppance was his largest connection. Montresor wants to get back at Fortunato, but nobody knows exactly why. In the story, Fortunato accidentally gives hints talking about a girl when he mentions “Will not they be awaiting us at the palazzoㅡthe Lady Fortunato at the rest? Let us be gone” (239). Fortunato was intoxicated, he did not even know that he was going to be murdered. He did not know what he was really saying, and him unintentionally commenting about a lady, was not the most intelligent thing to state. Poe relates to the story because his lady was taken away in his own life. The author of “Edgar Allan Poe Biography” under “Early Life” states “He

"In one case out of a hundred a point is excessively discussed because it is obscure; in the ninety-nine remaining it is obscure because it is excessively discussed." This quote by Edgar Allan Poe describes his obscure works which have been discussed and criticized in great detail for many years to come. Some readers believe that his works are too dark and eccentric maybe even deathly. Others believe his works to be masterpieces. However, one thing that is not up for debate is the fact that Edgar Allan Poe is a literary genius. Edgar Allan Poe, the creator of the ratiocinative story and the amateur sleuth and leading contributor to the gothic genre, is the greatest author of the mid-nineteenth century.

An inference we can make about Edgar Allan Poe is that he writes to show the downsides of love. In the article "A Terrible Evil": Edgar Allan Poe Writes About His Wife's Illness and Death” by Rebecca Onion it states, “ Again in about a year afterward. Then again — again — again & even once again at varying intervals. Each time I felt all the agonies of her death — and at each accession of the disorder I loved her more dearly & clung to her life with more desperate pertinacity.” Poe’s wife was constantly ill and each time she became better Poe had hope, but them she would fall ill again and Poe would be in agony. This relates to the inference that Edgar Allan Poe writes to show the downsides of love because he is in agony due to his wife’s constant

is made through his use of punctuation, word choice, figurative language, tone, and sentence structure.

Edgar Allen Poe, one of the world's greatest writers. This report will be about the life, death, and legacy of Edgar Allen Poe. Edgar Allen Poe has my noteworthy achievements along with a quite interesting life. With the influences he had as a child and his Virginia education here is the story of Edgar Allen Poe, one of history's greatest writers.

A struggling writer during the 1840’s is undoubtedly one of the strongest and well-known writers today. Commonly referred to as “The father of the detective story”, Poe’s graphic-gothic work certainly caught the attention of the public, who collectively believe his strange work unintentionally reveals his own troubled mind. His famous piece of work, The Black Cat, reveals the psychology of guilt and delivers varied emotions including superstition, hatred, love, sudden mental and personality transformation, which are all conveyed through Pluto. Literary devices in The Black Cat, along with Poe’s outstanding knowledge of the complex human mind and mental disorders prior to its discovering, reveal the nameless narrator’s unstable mental condition.

Edgar Allan Poe and Richard Connell are both amazing writers of wonderful imagery. In Poe’s story, “The Cask of Amontillado”, the protagonist, Montressor, sought revenge on Fortunado by killing him in the catacombs. In Connell's story, "The Most Dangerous Game", the protagonist, Rainsford, was on a yacht before he fell off it and swam to Ship-Trap Island. He knocked on a door to a house and then met General Zaroff who hunted him. Both of the stories were very interesting to read.

Poe's detective fiction or mystery fiction can best be felt in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes. Sherlock Holmes is one of the best knows detectives in the history of literature. His fame can be spotted in the books that have been written and the movies that have been produced about Holmes. Poe's works were able to influence the author of the Sherlock Holmes series, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, in which he based the character of Sherlock Holmes off of one of Poe's characters whose name was Dupin who was used in the mystery story The Murders in the Rue Morgue. The similarities between the two characters are quite grand. “Both are solitary men who prefer to live quietly in either isolation or in the company of one close companion.”(“Nineteenth Century Influenced Poe”). Both men also tend to shift to the bottom of their mysteries without a large amount of clues that other detective writers appear to have in their stories. The impact that Poe has had on authors and stories cannot be matched. His stories have provided a model for future authors to use, in the hope of growing the notoriety of mystery fiction or the horror genre.

This article published in the peer-reviewed journal College Literature, Vol.8 analysis Edgar Allen Poe’s depiction of Dupin as a perverse, inhuman character, and his distinctive method appearing throughout other texts of Poe’s. Written by Daniel Marder, this article serves as a reliable academic source, proven in its publication within a peer-reviewed journal, and its online publication by The John Hopkins University Press, a University press that publishes academic articles for students online. The article makes frequent reference to other texts by Edgar Allen Poe, drawing from literary devices and consistencies between multiple stories, indicating its orientation on the works of Poe and his portrayal of character. Through its publication

The vision of the mind is easily portrayed through the art of literature, painting a picture with the stroke of words. The natural inspiration that influences the creation of these works is derived from the life and the experiences of the creator. For some, these tales become stories and those stories become novels, but for one man it meant so much more. The works of Edgar Allan Poe became his life; he expressed every feeling and every moment of his existence through ink and paper. Poe involved his entire life in his writing, leaving no element of the story untouched by his trademark of a past. His work became so unique and unorthodox, yet it did not lack the attention it deserved. The American critic, Curtis Hidden Page, suggested that

The Portable Edgar Allen Poe, edited by J. Gerald Kennedy, is a phenomenal compilation of works from one of America's greatest writers of the nineteenth century. Published in 2006, the book contains short stories, poems, and letters, written by Edgar Allen Poe. Full of lies, hope, revenge, and guilt, the stories in this assemblage are suspenseful and convey powerful messages.

Edgar Allan Poe work can be related to allot of literature criticisms, but it is most familiarized with psychoanalytic criticism and New Historicism because the stories he wrote had allot to do with the mind and how people would behave also he wrote stories based off old history and beliefs.