1. What is the title of the text and what is the text about?
The title of the text is Popular Mechanics, and is about a man and woman fighting over their baby right before their separation. The fight turns physical, with the man and woman each pulling on the baby, and ends when the man gives it one final hard pull.
2. What is the author’s view? How do I know?
The author's view is that when people fight, they can end up wanting to win for winning's sake, disregarding their negative impact on people around them, even those that they love. I deduced this from the way that the author presented the actions of the man and woman. It appears that the man may have overlooked the baby altogether had the woman not taken away the baby's picture. And then
…show more content…
For example, the story starts with an ominous tone because the author chooses to describe the water as dirty, and the environment becoming dark. He shows the destruction of a beautiful thing by choosing to describe the knocking down of a flower pot during the struggle. He showed the disregard of the baby's well-being by choosing to describe the baby like an object while the man and woman are fighting over it.
4. Is the evidence valid? How do I know?
The evidence presented by the author is valid if it feels realistic. For the evidence to feel realistic, I have to be able to empathize with the characters during their struggles, and be able to picture the described events happening in the real world. In this case, Carver does a good job painting a realistic environment and allowing the characters to behave realistically, such that their brutal actions are believable.
5. Is the evidence relevant? How do I know?
There may have been events described that were not directly relevant to the author's view, but since overall the story paints a convincing picture of the author's view, there must have been enough relevant evidence
Cotton Mather had an issue with how Bishop’s case was handled, and how the court proceeded with other cases much like hers during this time. He sought to purge the court system of the use of spectral evidence as grounds for conviction. He felt like a man’s word was not enough to prove someone innocent or guilty, but that one needed hard evidence in order to ensure that the ruling was just. Mather’s “call[ed] for caution in his publications
The principal representation of truth in ‘The Trials of Oz’ is Robertson’s detailed presentation of the initial courtroom battle, including lengthy
The prosecution’s case relies on proving that Blyton was not acting in self-defence and that he made a conscious decision to kill his father. This argument is supported partially by the fact that when Blyton was rushed, Livingstone no longer had possession of the knife that made his initial assault threatening. Furthermore, Blyton gave 6 other versions of the event to various people which do not mention that he was acting in
When it comes to the presentation of the information in this article Brown excels in crediting himself. When he references the many interviews, he has with different people involved within the case this increases his credibility because it shows that he took the time out to individually interview each of these people to discover the truth behind what happened in the case.
I think a Natural Law School follower would have found the men not guilty of murder. Again this is based upon the reading, back story,
In life, sometimes random events will lead to one’s death. These two stories, “Popular Mechanics” and “A Good Man is Hard to Find”, both portray this idea. “Popular Mechanics,” written by Raymond Carver, has a baby torn apart by its own mother and father's hate for one another. The mother randomly saw the picture of the child and took it, and this stirred up emotions in the both of them. Enough emotions to stop paying attention to the child’s well being. “A Good Man is Hard to Find” is written by Flannery O’Connor, and in it a family of six crash because of their cat, and a murderer of a sort drives by randomly, eventually leading to the death of them all. In these two stories, both the important characters die in the climax, and both characters, baby and cat, are catalysis in the story. The style of each story is negative writing and destructive in nature.
Momaday uses a colorful description to explain what he sees while he’s visiting Rainy Mountain. These descriptions paint a bright image in the readers mind.
This is done through two avenues. First the author writes “to prove this, let Facts be submitted to a candid world” (Jefferson). The phrase candid world implies honesty to the whole world not just the reader, making this statement an outline for the rest that follows to be a shadowed truth now unveiled. The second avenue the author takes is to explicitly list each grievance that the author has tried to dispute and work through without avail. Writing in this manner reconfirms the message to the reader that all crimes have been long suffered and repeatedly shows the effort on the part of the author to alleviate
The two tug back and forth for the baby, and in the end the two both yank at the baby closing the story with, “In this manner, the issue was decided,” (Carver 2). This leaves the reader up in the air on what happened, the reader is
Why do the words that authors use in their writing help set the overall atmosphere of the story? In the story, "What Do Fish Have to Do With Anything," a young boy named Willie and his cautious mother, who were abandoned by their father, come across a beggar, and Willie grows curious of his character, thus leading him to question him. After a series of encounters, Willie learns that the homeless man was not what he seemed, but a man of wisdom. In the story, “Dark They Were, And Golden Eyed” by Ray Bradbury, a party of humans arrive in Mars and try to build their new lives there after an apocalypse on the Earth. One of the humans, Harry Bittering, is skeptical about Mars and how living there may not be the best idea. In both “Dark They Were,
literary devices such as point of view and symbolism to give it a more dramatic effect and add to the madness the narrator portrays.
The short story “Little Things” by Raymond Carver deals with the humanity’s spiteful nature and its desire to flaunt what others can not have. On the surface, the story is about a man, a woman, and baby, none of which have a confirmed relation to each other, and a dispute over who should keep the baby after the man leaves. As the story reaches its end, there is no clear winner and the reader has a sense of unease based on the last line, “In this manner, the issue was decided” (Carver). Carver’s use of dialogue, allusion, and sight/sound imagery help build the darker mood for the story, and his use of those elements ultimately leads to one of Carver’s main messages. By utilizing the previously listed items, Carver highlights the idea that
For example, the author narrates, “He moped through the whole day at school. He couldn’t answer any questions nor read any words. He couldn’t even tell anyone the pony was sick, for that might make him sicker. And when school was finally out he started home in dread” (26). This demonstrates how helpless Jody felt during his pony’s sickness. Also, the text implies that the tone is meant to be depressing since the author uses pessimistic writing while describing Jody’s day at school. Furthermore, Steinbeck narrates, “Below, in one of the little clearings in the brush lay the red pony. In the distance, Jody could see the legs moving slowly and compulsively. And in a circle around him stood the buzzards, waiting for the moment of death they know so well” (35). This shows the suspenseful moment when Jody spots the pony just as it is about to die. Also, the reader can predict the emotions that are stirring inside Jody at the moment as he witnesses his first pony succumb. To sum up, the suspenseful and depressing tones contribute to making the story more enjoyable as well as much more
The readers first impression of the couple is dialogue. Dialogue is a very important element that contributes to the tone in “Popular Mechanics”. The dialogue in this story is almost exclusively short. The first time the reader gets dialogue is after the author sets the scene and initial mood. “I’m glad you’re leaving! I’m glad you’re leaving! She said. Do you hear?” (277). This automatically sets an aggressive and tense tone to the story. The reader is never told what the couple is breaking up over, the only thing the reader gets is that the couple is fighting over keeping the baby. The couple only really says that they want the baby, that is the majority of the dialogue in the story. Unspoken dialogue in “Popular Mechanics” is immensely important to the story. “He was in the bedroom pushing clothes into a suitcase when she came to the door” (277). This example shows the distance between the couple. The woman is constantly backing away and seemingly running away from the man, especially with the baby. There is finality in the story even though the reader never knows what the issues are in the relationship, why the man is leaving, or why they are separating. “In this manner, the issue was decided” (278). This short sentence sets the final tone of the story. There is something sinister and aggressive about this sentence. The audience does not know exactly what the issue is, but with the small
The writer of a fiction text uses plot, setting and characters to create imagery and influence the reader's response to how the author wishes the reader to perceive a situation. This can be done through many methods, which include detailed descriptions of any settings, detail of weather, characters stereotypical of society and colour association.