preview

Power In J. R. Tolkien's The Lord Of The Rings

Good Essays

J.R.R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings saga and Peter Jackson’s movie renditions have been accused of including many complicated or otherwise controversial social and cultural themes such as orientalism, racism, sexism and homosexuality. Many scholars over the decades have debated whether or not if it was Tolkien that harbored these feelings, or if it was just his characters. More recently many people have brought up that Jackson blatantly ignored significant aspects of the original story.
Astrid Winegar wrote in her essay “Aspects of Orientalism in J. R. R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings” that the Lord of the Rings ‘is replete with themes that directly pertain to discourses involving Orientalism.’ Her argument showing that there are indeed classic …show more content…

Many take the lack of strong female roles in his story to be sexist, which on the contrary it isn’t, as Nancy Enright points out in her essay titled ‘Tolkien's Females And The Defining Of Power’. Tolkien challenged the views of power in the Lord of the Rings in many different ways, including gentler and wiser forms of power which are shown through his female characters, especially Galadriel and Arwen. Arwen has power that comes in a quiet, but potent way. By sacrificing her immortality so she can marry Aragorn, she awakens something inside Aragorn that Elrond, Arwen’s father, says will allows “by my loss [i.e. of Arwen] the kingship of Men may be restored”(Enright 97). Enright states “Galadriel is the most powerful female figure in The Lord of the Rings and, in fact, one of the most important characters of either gender in the story”(Enright 99). Galadriel not only is magically powerful, but she also has the strength to ‘pass the test’ of the temptation of the …show more content…

They travel, fight, and survive together while constantly being in danger. Despite the fellowship being very close, no two characters were closer than Samwise Gamgee and Frodo Baggins. “Throughout the story, the two hobbits are openly affectionate, often described as sleeping together, holding hands, even sobbing with feelings of affection for one another”(Kaufman). He also states “The homoerotic aspects of this motif of male partnership are strikingly evident in Tolkien's novel, in which Sam is portrayed as much more than just a close friend to Frodo”(Kaufman). I do not believe this is true. Tolkien had explained in multiple letters that the relationship between Sam and Frodo was inspired from his experiences with comrades in World War I, which were most likely not homosexual in nature. Kaufman is reaching for something that just isn’t there. War and life threatening situations bring together people in intense ways. The relationship Sam and Frodo has is platonic. You can love someone with your whole being and be affectionate without sexual desires. Other than almost forcing a homosexual related connection between the fellowship, namely Sam and Frodo, his essay does contain interesting aspects and views but I do not support his thesis or believe that he is

Get Access