Problem Of Evil Argument

God and the logical problem of evil is a debate among philosophers which states that the possibility of an omnipotent and omnibenevolent God in a world where evil exists is impossible. The issue claims that if God were really all powerful and all good, then he would prevent evil from happening in the world. The logical argument relies on the Christian definition of God which states that God must be either all-knowing or all good. I think this definition is misunderstanding, because it is a human bias and expects God to be loving and always serve us. So does evil prove that God does not exist? Not necessarily. I believe that God and evil can exist together because the standard definition of a God does not have to be true. He might not be either all knowing, all powerful, and more importantly, he might not be all good.

Important point: Evil does not mean God does NOT exist, but only implies that God’s probably has a lesser chance of existing.

The Logical Argument from Evil follows the construct of the modus tollens, where it states that God cannot be all-powerful, all-loving and all-knowing if Evil exists in the world. The Empirical Argument is an inductive argument that explains how God is a neutral, powerful being that collects data on both the good and evil in the world. Thus, God is indifferent to mankind’s pain and suffering, and also happiness. Since evil exists, this argument’s conclusion is fully supported. The Logical Argument thus states that God cannot be this supreme, powerful being whereas The Empirical Argument supports God’s credibility as the supreme all-knowing, all-powerful and all-loving.

Have you ever stopped to think of why animals, especially harmless ones such as rabbits or deer sometimes die a painful death even when humans are not involved and is deemed unnecessary? If there was a God as most commonly referred to in the Abrahamic religions (Christianity,Islam,Judaism), an all powerful, all knowing, and all good God, wouldn't this divine being be able to prevent such events? The Problem of Evil is an argument that shows that God cannot be either all powerful, all knowing or all good because there is evil in the world and these two things contrast each other making them unable to coexist, therefore disclaiming the notion of the existence of God. Furthermore, this argument can be broken into two different types of reasoning to support the clause,one of induction and the other of deduction. In this essay, I will examine the argument for the Problem of Evil, a possible theodicy against the argument, and reply to the theodicy.

Arguments against God and His existence have been a constant occurrence throughout history. From the beginning of time there have always been people that rebel against God and argue against the fiber of his existence. There are many naturalists who argue against God and whether or not he exists or is present in the world. These ideas and arguments are based on the reality of evil and clearly deviate from God’s word of scripture. There are theists who have opposing arguments against these naturalists. These theists believe in the existence of God and believe that he is present in the world and in the lives of people. The naturalist argument against God and the arguments of theist have always been constantly debated with and against

Now the problem here is that if there is a God, then why does evil exist? Here the question it self begins to doubt that if evil exist, then God is not an all powerful perfect being. These are the arguments given:

The existence of evil does not prove that there is not a good God. The author makes a very good case against this argument. Evil points to the existence of a good God. God was in existence before there was evil so to say that evil proves there is no God is false. Some people say that evil points away from God’s existence, however, their claim has no support. The fact that we think and speak evil is proof that there is a good God because

What is your opinion on the problem of evil? Many people say that God does not exist because of the problem of evil. In the book, the problem of evil is defined as one of the greatest critiques against the theistic religions of the world (104). The argument for the problem of evil in the book is this: “If God existed as an omnipotent, omnibenevolent, and omniscient being, then evil cannot exist in his creation. Evil does exist in his creation.

Like mentioned before, there are two versions of the intellectual problem of evil. First lets explore the logical version. This is that it is logically impossible for evil and God to both exist. This can be compared to an irresistible force and an immovable object both existing. So since we all can clearly see and agree that evil definitely does exist, God must not. Although Nt Wright, a British New Testament scholar and many others, suggests we

Another argument can made regarding the existence of god is morals. What is right? What is wrong? Are morals objective, or subjective? If morals are objective, something must have put it there, that thing being god. You can argue and say that morals are objective and are there by a god, and if we all were to suddenly die, the morals we went by would still exist. In that case, the only thing that makes an act morally wrong is what god prohibits you from doing it. Is killing wrong because god prohibits it, or does god prohibit killing because it is already wrong? Now you can also argue that morals are subjective and that whatever you do is right according to you. But if morals are subjective, then god does not exist. We create morals

God exists. That is the truth and once that fact is clearly established, our understanding of evil is clear. Proof of God’s existence can be reached through reason alone, outside of the church. Arguments against God’s existence may be based heavily on the belief that if God were real there would be no evil in the world. However, as God’s existence is proven through logical steps of reason, so also is the existence of evil explained. Aquinas’ Five Proofs are an excellent point to start understanding God’s existence. We can show that God exists through the complexity of our planet and by the uniformity of the laws the universe operates by.

Evil cannot be disproven and it is beneficial to existence overall. Atheists and Christians alike may be troubled is the question of why evil exist? Why does God let evil exist? If he is all-powerful and good why would he do that? The idea of a forgiving omnipotent God allowing the presence of moral evil seems conflicting. We are created in his image, if God is good why do we tend to sin? To understand this it is important to know the distinctions between the two primary categories of evil. Theologians and Philosophers such as Aquinas or Nietzsche recognize that with

Atheists then give an example that assumes that “lighting attacks a lifeless tree causing a forest fire. In the fire a fawn is stuck and horrifying scared and lies in awful pain for numerous days beforehand death releases its grief”. Atheists see this sorrow of the fawn as pointless. For there does not seem to be any better good such that the deterrence of the better good such that the avoidance of the fawns suffering would require either the loss of that good or occurrence of an evil equally bad or worse. Atheist argue the problem to evil is that an almighty being could have easily stopped the fawn from being extremely burned or, given the burning, could have spared around the fawn or it could have quickly ended its life, rather than permitting

Evil is a problem in the philosophy of religion because there is no real answer. According to eastern religions, “God is good, God is all-powerful and evil exists in the world” (Davies-Stofka,

The existence of evil is unquestionable. In our lives we have all experienced at some kind of pain. We have all had some kind of emotional or physical pain in our life. To believe in the existence of God we have to understand that what is evil? Well the simplest way to describe this would be that evil is something that causes suffering to human beings. First we can all agree on that evil exists in this world from the fact that the history of humankind is full of wars, murders,