preview

Professor-Student Rapport Scale: Article Analysis

Decent Essays
Open Document

Randee May
10/26/15
Psych 4000
Professor Green

Article Critique 1: Professor-Student Rapport Scale

The topic of measurement in the article by Wilson et al., was to determine whether or not a professor-student rapport scale could predict student outcomes. As of 2007, according to Wilson et al., no scale existed to measure the professor-student rapport. Rapport being defined as, “a close or sympathetic relationship; agreement; harmony” (Wilson, Ryan, & Pugh, 2010). The researchers began by having 51 undergraduate students create statements that applied to their professor-student relationship and a 195 participants would take the survey during their class time for extra credit. Researchers had to take into consideration that immediacy and how it could have an effect on the relationship between professor and students, as well as how the professor behavior could influence a student’s scoring, whether it be verbal or non-verbal. However, according to Wilson et al., “immediacy does not measure rapport, for rapport is the positive relationship between teacher and student, while immediacy is a way to create that positive relationship.” …show more content…

The results showed that their hypothesis was correct, that the rapport held a higher significance of predication than that of immediacy, albeit immediacy correlates with rapport. Even with their results, the researchers were concerned with validity due to student’s objectivity, (Wilson, Ryan, & Pugh, 2010). A suggestion to avoid objectivity in future research would be to use the grades of students, and to keep in mind that this professor-student rapport generated during this research was generalized for the college student environment. Yet another concern was the reliability of self-reports, which leads back to using the grades of students as another important factor in the

Get Access