Pros And Cons Of Keeping Undocumented Immigrants

Undocumented immigrants pay state and local taxes. Many also pay property taxes and excise taxes like any American citizen would. In the article “Do undocumented Immigrants Pay Their “Fair Share” of Taxes (PRO)” (Wiehe, Meg etall,) it states that,

Each year thousands of mexicans cross the border illegally to find work in the united states. Most perform jobs that U.S citizens won’t do, and they pay taxes, some argue they should receive amnesty. However, opponents argue that aliens are a drain on the system and a threat to security, they should be deported. Should undocumented workers in the united states be allowed to stay? Undocumented workers in the united states should be allowed to stay in the united states. America is spending billions of dollars on different reform plans.

Once immigrants arrive in America, they face having to live in fear of being deported. Over 72,000 immigrants with children were deported in 2013, according to reports confirmed by ICE. In a book I read, Enrique's journey, Enrique was almost deported back to Central America after living for years with his family in America. His daughter had to visit him in jail and wonder if he would be there the next day. It is not our place to split up immigrant families, the so called American Dream is the promise that everyone will be treated equally, regardless of social class or birthplace.

Illegal immigrants should be given the right to benefits in the U.S. Illegal immigrants are willing to take all kinds of jobs that Americans don't want. According to Green Garage Blog “When it comes to doing household chores, cleaning, feeding the pets and taking care of an adult in need of care and attention, an illegal immigrant can take on these types of jobs. And knowing how busy working Americans are, it helps to get support from someone”(10 Critical Pros and Cons of Illegal immigration). Illegal immigrants can start working in the U.S doing jobs that Americans don’t want like the ones stated above. This could be the gateway to helping them get a pension, retirement plan, and a 401k. Most illegal immigrants have been in the U.S for a while

Illicit immigrants originate from another nation, so financial issues can emerge when there are excess measures of emigration. Such a pattern can destabilize outside nations and diminish the ability of U.S. firms to fare products to those countries. In 2010, the normal unlawful immigrant family unit receives around $24,721 in government advantages and administrations while paying some $10,334 in taxes. This produced a normal yearly financial shortage (benefits got less expenses paid) of around $14,387 per family unit. This cost must be borne by U.S. citizens. Under current law, all illegal immigrant family units together have a total yearly shortfall of around $54.5 billion.

June 2012 was a year with a huge break through on illegal immigration, and the fight to set the decision right. Opportunities to improve immigrants careers, schooling, and lives, who were born in the United States and plan on staying are on the rise. Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) was created to provide immigrants with an opportunity to stay in the States “legally,” but continue their lives through education if graduating from an U.S. high school, going to college, serving in the armed forces, and eventually gain citizenship in the United States. Many U.S. citizen have many thoughts and views on illegal immigrants and immigration in general, and the pros and cons to having DACA support illegal immigrants to stay in the country. There is a huge decision in process currently in 2017 that is putting DACA in risk from being a Federal Program that would end up effecting many immigrants. Threatening deportation and the possibility of losing everything that DREAMers have worked up to and for and are continuing to work towards is at a huge risk of just being thrown away. Keeping DACA and protecting the DREAMers is important because mentally and physically they are just as much of a U.S. citizen as anyone else born in the U.S.

Several illegal immigrants buy a fake identification that they get from people who are selling it for a few hundred dollars. “They get on the payroll by using fake or fraudulent social security numbers or social security numbers of the deceased”(Germano). Another way for an illegal immigrant to get on the payroll is by getting an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number. According to Roy Germano “Immigrants now file their income taxes using Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers (ITINs)”. Even though they have a number that they use to pay taxes, illegal immigrants also have to pay taxes for everything they buy including food, house rent, and other items. “Immigrants—legal and undocumented—all buy things, and thus pay these taxes as part of their purchase”. Immigrants are consumers just like everyone else in America. They have things that they have to buy to survive in this country, so they should be treated with respect regardless of their status.

Thank you for your thoughtful post. In other words, you are asking how can the United States justify not providing affordable health insurance for people residing and working in country? Baiden (2010) offerings two important points, “Most, if not all of these undocumented immigrants work hard and contribute to the country's economic growth” furthermore, “The problem is that such individuals suffer high degree of exploitation at the hands of their employers” (p. 5). Undocumented immigrants are ineligible for government insurance programs, are unlikely to have employer provided insurance, and often do not have the resources to purchase private insurance. Furthermore, research has identified vulnerable populations such as low income, uninsured

Illegal immigration and the deployment of these undocumented inhabitants of America has been a disputed issue for decades. It is debated whether to return the illegal immigrants to their country of origin, or to let them stay in the United States. Factual evidence and statistics has proven that although the immigrants may not be authorized as citizens or inhabitants of America, they do contribute to the diversity of the country. With such a large population of foreigners, the immigrants also influence America’s economy and the workforce. Immigration has been a prevalent aspect of civilization in the United States for centuries, and it is clear that allowing these illegal aliens to remain in the country will keep the economy and workforce secure. Since the immigrants have immensely escalated since the 1920s, it would drastically affect the nation to deploy all of these people. The deployment of illegal immigrants would negatively impact the economy, diversity, workforce, and stability of the United States, and undocumented immigrants should therefore be allowed to stay in America.

When it comes to the discussion of taxing unlawful immigrants, there are a plethora of opinions ranging high and wide as it pertains to whether unlawful immigrants exemplify a surplus or deficit in this economic sense. A report titled, “The Fiscal Cost of Unlawful Immigrants and Amnesty to the U.S. Taxpayer” claims that unlawful immigrants cause large fiscal cost for U.S. taxpayers by paying less than they receive. Jason Richwine, who is credited with a Ph.D. at Harvard and Robert Rector propose that there are four types of services and benefits that are applicable to this issue.

An American citizen who visits other countries is somehow automatically protected, held to certain regards and given certain liberties, which sometimes the “Citizens” of those countries do not receive. Americans can travel to just about any country without a visa or any form of legal documents. Aside from a passport, they can choose to reside in that country simply because they want to without any form of backlash, ill treatment, or fear for their lives. They get some of the better jobs pushing the locals out of those positions. Therefore, illegal immigrants in the United States do have some constitutional rights that citizens have.

As history has shown, millions of immigrants have flocked to the United States in attempts to find a better life. The complexity of immigration is much greater now than it was in the early 1900’s. Most immigrants arriving on boats to Ellis Isle would have only been denied if they were deemed to be a criminal or with disease. Individuals must now endure an extensive application process to obtain a green card or visa. Without one of these documents, the person is considered to be here illegally. Today we have scores of people attempting to circumvent the laws of our country by crossing the border and many prove successful. These undocumented immigrants, otherwise known as illegals, continue to be a hot topic of debate in our country. Estimates currently stand at around 11 million illegal immigrants in the United States today. Of theses 11 million, 41 percent reside in either California or Texas. The overwhelming majority of illegal entrance into the US takes place at the southern border from Mexico. In this paper I will attempt to explain how illegal immigrants play in role in employment, our society, and how they impact the overall economic welfare of the United States.

However, they might not have noticed how important illegal immigrants are in the American economy. Despite the fact illegal immigrants have no documents; they contribute billions of dollars to the Social Security Administration yearly and get nothing back when they retire (Porter 10). There is not an exact amount how much they contribute, however, researchers indicate that illegal immigrant contribute roughly around $ 7 billion to Social Security Administration (Porter 10). Illegal immigrants are classified as undocumented people in the United States, but that does not mean they do not help fund state and local taxes. They must file their taxes yearly. IRS enacted a system called, Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) to track illegal immigrants who are employed. There is not an exact number that measures how many illegal immigrants pay taxes yearly, but many of them definitely pay their taxes for the IRS yearly which benefits the U.S. economy. (Lipman

For ages, the United States has seemed to be the country where people seek to move to for a better life. The United States was built on immigrants. People have always migrated to the United States both legally and illegally. The main problem the country has face with immigrants is the amount that trespass the border illegally. Illegal immigration is the unlawful act of crossing a national border(Illegal Immigration Pros and Cons). The illegal immigrant population keeps growing at an annual average of about 300,000 people(Currie 10). In the recent year of 2014, there were about 11.3 million undocumented people living in the United States(Krogstad). Many have asked what harm they do to both the economy and the American citizen. Although there are many arguments as to how much harm they cause, there are as many arguments stating illegal immigration benefits the United States. Illegal immigration has a positive impact in the United States within the consumers, the working class, and the overall economy.

This seems to be one of the most popular topics in both political and day-to-day conversations. Here is the simple answer: yes. In other words, yes, undocumented immigrants should be granted amnesty by the federal government. According to the ITEP, unauthorized immigrants as a whole paid $10.6 billion in local and state taxes, so why not give them the life that they’ve already paid for?