Creating Your Arguments
The Mongols undeniably killed millions of people in their conquest of foreign lands: historians debate exactly how many, but there is no doubt that the Mongol invasion was a tragedy of epic proportions for those in their path. However, when we look beyond the initial conquest, we need to ask, “what were the long-term effects of the Mongol empire”? When we do, we see a lot of positive effects that left the lands they occupied permanently changed, and in many ways for the better.
Red = Charlie Black = Keenan
Arguments in Favor of Your Position:
1.
Evidence: Trade Genghis Khan offered many services for merchants and traders, which helped revolutionize trade
Protection, tax exemption, loans, and consistent aid
Traders
…show more content…
Goods such as gold, manuscripts, astronomical tomes, and porcelain were now heading towards Asia Spices, teas, artwork, and silk traveled west towards Europe. Gunpowder reached the Arabs, and eventually the Europeans via trade on the Silk Road
Under Mongol rule, merchants and travelers were guaranteed safety, “It was said that a person could walk from one end of the Empire to the other with a gold plate on their head and not be robbed”
2. The Mongols were extremely tolerant many religions during the Mongol Empire
Evidence: Religious Tolerance
The Mongols practiced Shamanism (or Tengrism, Mongolian shamanistic beliefs)
This was a form of animism, particularly the worshiping of the spirits of their home land located in Mongolia
Because of this practice, when the Mongolians absorbed a kingdom, they didn’t expect/force their own specific religion on them
In fact, many practiced a fusion of two religions, and some even fully converted
This lead them to be very tolerant towards other
…show more content…
Pax Mongolica(Mongol Peace) was a period of time where peace, stability, economic growth, cultural fusion and cultural development
Evidence: Pax Mongolica
This happened under the Mongol Empire and its occupied territories
This allowed for the thriving of the Silk Road trading(between Asia and Europe)
Low tariffs on the Silk road and fewer political entities to cross increased trade cultural interchange and wealth for all
It permitted the spreading new ideas, sciences, and technologies
Because of the Mongols, there was mass cultural expansion around Europe and Asia.
The Pax Mongolica created international communication beyond the world that feudal states in Europe and Eurasia knew (and the Mongols had a system similar to the pony express that allowed critical information to travel rapidly from one end of their empire to the other
Influx of Turkic populations in Eurasia and Middle East resulting from the Mongol invasion gave rise to Turkic dynasties in the region and eventually to the Ottoman Empire
One could argue that the Mongolian Empire kickstarted the Renaissance
Arguments Against You Opponent's Position:
Living in other kingdoms was not good for outside religions
Evidence: Church Non
1. What was the impact of the mongol conquest of Russia? Of the Islamic heartlands?
The Mongols were nomadic pastoralists who originated in the Eurasian steppes but eventually conquered the largest contiguous empire in history. The first ruler Genghis Khan was able to unite the loosely-bound nomadic clans in 1206 AD and begin seizing land through ingenious military tactics such as base-10 warrior organization, trickery, and terror. Later, his grandson Kublai Khan continued conquering new land and adding it to their vast yet relatively decentralized government. Although there were a few positive effects of Mongol rule, they still had an overall negative impact on Eurasia because of the large quantities of deaths they caused and their weakening of Chinese power in their own government.
The Pax Mongolica is an important reason why the Mongolian empire had a positive impact on Eurasia because both the Mongols and other regions were able to gain needed resources and survive longer. These routes not only posed as routes for trade, but also acted as a way for communication throughout the empire, as depicted on document 1. The rise of the Pax Mongolica helped enforce safer and better trade. It gave Eurasia a well needed time of peace and prosperity since the Mongols hadn’t halted their invasions. During this time merchants were able to travel from one end of the empire to another with a lower risk of being attacked. This blossomed trade since goods were successfully transported throughout Eurasia for a duration that would keep cities surviving. The collapse of the Pax Mongolica was also a positive for Eurasia because the decline in trade and the collapse of the Mongolian empire led to an “Age of Exploration” -Document 7. This Age of Exploration began with Christopher Columbus, and westerners searching for new routes to China and India. Document 7 states; “Thus, the Mongols indirectly led to European exploration and the intrusion of Europeans into Asia. These are both positive effects the Mongols had on Eurasia because without the rise and the fall of the Pax Mongolica more regions around the world, including Eurasia would be left
The Mongol Empire, an infamous empire in due to its oppressively powerful army, had an unavoidable influence on Eurasia including both positive effects, such as advancing trade and production of goods in less advanced societies (doc 5) as well as laying a powerful and protective influence on a number of societies (doc 2), and negative effects, being savagely murderous towards those societies in their path (doc 1), destroying important structures and cities of other societies (doc 7), and aggressively demanding a tribute be paid to them from Christian societies and others (doc 9), as well as effects that are considered neither negative nor positive effects, examples being that the Khan leader did not convert to Christianity when confronted
Through their conquests and strong-handed rule, Genghis Khan and his sons and grandsons who followed him created stability and peace in the Mongol Empire in the 1200s and 1300s. Historians now refer to this period of order as the Pax Mongolica, or “Mongol Peace.” You may recall that the years between 27 BC and 180 AD of the Roman Empire are known as the Pax Romana, or the “Roman Peace” because of the prosperity in the Roman Empire that resulted from a strong centralized government and few wars. The same was true for the Pax Mongolica.
Mongol Empire was the biggest land empire in history. Its territory extended from the Yellow Sea in eastern Asia to the borders of eastern Europe. It existed from 1206 and 1368, about 200 years. The overall impact of the Mongols was positive. The Mongols paved the way for a lot of modern societies.
The Pax Mongolica, also known as the Mongol Peace and Pax Tatarica, was brought up at the end of the time of Mongols’ conquests. Western Scholars designated the fourteenth century as the Pax Mongolica. The Pax Mongolica contributed to the development of a new global culture because the Mongol Khans pursued peaceful trade and diplomacy (220). The bubonic plague epidemic of the 1300s led to the destruction of the Mongol Empire because of the deaths it caused; also, the plague had demoralized the living and deprived the Mongol Golden Family of its primary source of support by cutting off trade and tribute (247).
With its massive territorial size, also came its massive impact on the world, especially in trade. Trade has shaped regions for years, allowing for the spread of ideas, influence, and the effects on economies around the world, and the Mongols have transformed that trade, some for better or worse. The Mongols were both constructive and destructive during their rule, and the terms construction and destruction in this essay refer to whether the Mongols built things up in that region, or if they destroyed things
Jack Weatherford’s Genghis Khan and the Making of the Modern World provides a refreshing and insightful perspective on the Mongol Empire and their impact on history. Weatherford ardently dispels stereotypes often associated with Genghis Khan and the Mongols while highlighting their significant achievements that immensely induced them and the modern world. As Weatherford explained the history of Temujin, I found myself admiring how he overcame various hardships and created a destiny for himself. He not only created an empire, “he built a new and unique system based on individual merit, loyalty, and achievement.” (Weatherford xix)
Also, while conquering this abundance of land, the Mongols did kill much people. This was look upon as ruthless and unpeaceful. But, what people don't know is that after the
Mongolian conquests and invasions devastated affected areas and left survivors terrified. To all areas they have invaded including Tangut cities, Novgorod, and Nishapur, Mongols treated inhabitants harshly and most of the time, killed them (Doc.1, 2, 3, 6). Monks
Towards the end of the post classical period, during the early twelfth century new empires rose to power. Specifically, the Mongol Empire located in the steppes of Central Asia. The Mongol Empire was started by Genghis Khan who was part of a nomadic clan. Khan used his position as leader of the clan to unite all the clans in the area to create a very powerful army, which he then used to expand further and conquer empires such as China, Russia, the Middle East, and and the city of Baghdad creating the Mongol Empire. The Mongol Empire controlled the most land of any empire. As the Mongol Empire conquered new Empires they effected them through the environment, social classes, politically economically, and their culture. Two empires that the Mongol Empire had an effect drastically on was China and Russia politically and economically. The Mongol Empire improved China and Russia economically by facilitating trade routes stabilizing China economy and helped Russia semi-stable their economy. Politically the Mongol Empire enforced a system which united the people in China and helped Russia develop a political system indirectly.
The Mongols were constantly conquering new lands of insanely large sizes. They acquired land masses as big as 4,860,000 square miles all around. (document one) They were like terrorists to another persons home and another mans land with their crude actions and constant killing. Genghis Kahn alone conquered the largest amount of land, in fact being 4,860,000 square miles. Thats bigger than the body of the United States alone, and there’s no way that this man acquired all this land just by marching in and asking if he could take over. He just took over with the complex army he’d formed. Their army was just as hardcore and serious as they were. The faults of one man could result in the death of ten. The act of ten men could result in the death of 100
The Mongols impacted the course of history in Eurasia, but the resulting destruction: ruined empires and the Black Death, lead to a need for rebuilding and reestablishing the once powerful empires from the Post-Classical time period from the fifteenth century. Ansary argues that the Mongol Holocaust had both positive and negative effects. Because of the Mongols, there was a new sense of global awareness and synchronizing that was reflected in similarities between different lands. Yet, the mass murdering and destruction from Timar was a definite low point. Even so, due to the destruction that resulted, communication and trade became world-wide and new, strong empires were born. They were fueled by new technology and unified by religion. The level of religious tolerance in each empire was determined by each empire’s interpretation of the Qur’an. Ansary highlights his opinion of the two most important products of post-Mongol rebirth, new interpretations of the Qur'an and Muslim religious theory as well as the emergence of Sufism, within the Ottoman, Safavid, and Mughal Empires.
Along with unity comes peace. The textbook says that the peace at this time was called Pax Mongolica, or the period of time where there was peace in the Mongol empire. This allowed the regions to communicate with one another. This also allowed Mongols safety as they traveled through their lands. Foreigners, such as traders were also allowed safety as they traveled throughout the Khanates. Also, the peace allowed the citizens themselves to move between the regions, allowing the people to travel to the different regions under the Mongol