preview

Ravinder Kaur Who Says You Re A Dane Summary

Decent Essays

In the article “who says you’re a dane?” author Ravinder Kaur takes a deep and Poignant look at the state of immigration and what it means to be “Danish” within the Danish culture and Danish politics. Throughout the article, Kaur provides numerous premises and pieces of evidence to support her two-part conclusion. The first part of the conclusion is that “Being a meaningful contributor to society was once deemed valuable in Denmark, enough to provide a sense of belonging. But now, it’s the bloodline that matters.” As well as the second part of the conclusion which is that “An anti-immigrant stance in Denmark is now neither masked in clumsy euphemisms nor accompanied by halfhearted gestures of conciliation toward the “New Danes”. The message is now delivered rough and raw by a new generation of outspoken politicians”. In her article, Kaur provides three statements by three different Danish politicians to premise her conclusion. The first premise she presents is a statement from Martin Henriksen, the chairman of a parliamentary committee on immigration, integration, and housing. On a televised exchange Henriksen said “This is not how one becomes Danish, one can’t say …show more content…

The structure of the article is valid and Kaur provides a lot of premises and pieces of evidence to support her conclusion. Also, I believe Kaur argument is sound because even though the premises and assumptions she presents in the article are not all rational, they all do in the end support and advance her conclusion that ““Being a meaningful contributor to society was once deemed valuable in Denmark, enough to provide a sense of belonging. But now, it’s the bloodline that matters.” and “An anti-immigrant stance in Denmark is now neither masked in clumsy euphemisms nor accompanied by halfhearted gestures of conciliation toward the “New Danes”. The message is now delivered rough and raw by a new generation of outspoken

Get Access