preview

Raymond Carver's 'So Much Water So Close To Home'

Good Essays

Known for his ‘Dirty Realism’ writing style (Rundle, 2007), Raymond Carver wrote about the tribulations of the American Working Class. In his short story, ‘So Much Water So Close To Home’ (1975), Claire’s husband, Stuart, and his three friends go on a fishing trip, only to discover the body of a young woman floating in the river shortly after arriving. Instead of contacting the authorities immediately they continue to fish beside the body until some two days later. Carver examines what ‘men owe women’ and what ‘the living owe the dead’ (Byrnes, 2006). Director Ray Lawrence and his screenwriter Beatrix Christian attempt to develop these themes further in their 2006 Australian adaptation, Jindabyne. While there have been many alterations to the narrative, the film still closely revolves around Carver’s concept of responsibility. Although both Carver and Lawrence have explored societal and moral issues, Jindabyne’s more modern observations may further develop the representation of gender and culture and, more importantly, preserve the intricate ethical pillars of Carver’s short.

‘So Much Water So Close To Home’ very closely looks at the innate polarity in men and women’s reactions when faced with both pain and pleasure, and it is this separation in behaviour that drives both versions of the narrative. As Claire narrates the short story, Carver creates a bias in its telling. She explicitly implies that every action of the men is inherently and intentionally evil. With Claire’s

Get Access