In watching the movie As Good as it Gets and reading the article Perceived Function of Worry, it is apparent that struggling with any of the indicated anxiety based disorders in the DSM V are extremely crippling and impair an individual’s ability to function normally in their daily lives. This poses the question of what issues are prevalent in coping with the diagnosis of an anxiety disorder, and what changes could be made to the Diagnostic Statistical Manual in the future to better accommodate the needs of the individuals facing the challenges that correspond with it.
In reading the article Perceived Function of Worry, Borkovec presents an interesting concept as he discusses some of the positive effects anxiety and worry could have on an
…show more content…
During one segment of the movie, As Good as it Gets, Melvin began to experience a mild panic attack when he was asked to leave the diner he goes to everyday due to displaying disruptive behavior after he found out the waitress that usually serves him was not at work. In the scene prior, Melvin had to return the dog he had been watching for several weeks to the owner. Due to his anxiety and OCD, it was challenging for Melvin to adjust to the change in his routine and the attachment he formed with the dog, which ultimately resulted in him lashing out at the diner. Aside from just observing how detailed and stress filled Melvin’s daily life was, what stood out the most for me was how people responded to him acting on his anxiety or compulsions. As a result of the anxiety Melvin was experiencing, he would often appear hostile towards other people and make inappropriate comments. Although people’s reactions to his behavior are understandable, it portrays how ignorant society is to the subjective experience of a person struggling with an anxiety disorder. As Melvin left the diner, all the people in the restaurant clapped because they felt his behavior was often rude and arrogant. However, they were unaware of the reasoning behind his actions and what he was experiencing to make him act in that particular
At 87 years old, Bob Wiley died last month at his house in New York. In his forties, Bob suffered from several specific phobias, dependent personality disorder, and panic disorder with agoraphobia. Bob was scared of being in enclosed or small spaces and of germs. He was so worried about getting an illness that he would use a tissue to touch a door or a car handle. Furthermore, he would always bring his pet goldfish Gil with him wherever he would go. When Mr. Wiley switched to Dr. Leo Marvin for therapy, Bob started to depend excessively on his psychiatrist. After Dr. Marvin left for vacation, Bob called Dr. Marvin twice to get help – once as himself and once acting like he was Lily Marvin, Dr. Marvin’s sister. Bob even faked his own death to get his psychiatrist’s vacation home address to see him during his vacation in New Hampshire. Then, after getting Leo Marvin’s address, Bob rode a bus from New York to New Hampshire to get help from Dr. Marvin. However, due to his
Alternatively Hadley (1995) puts forward the view that contrary to popular belief, anxiety actually arises out of thoughts of potential danger and not the actual danger that produces the symptoms of anxiety. In support of this view the document by Chrysalis states that “feelings of anxiety come from apprehension or fear, the source of which is not always recognisable”. Feeling anxious at certain times in our life is a normal instinctual response that serves as a protection to aid survival. It teaches us to avoid dangerous situations and in this way is a learning process however the subconscious can sometimes work overtime resulting in response to all situations that feel remotely similar to the one that has made us feel anxious in the first instance (Chrysalis 2010 1-5 pp7). This document describes how anxiety will affect our whole being, our emotions, our behaviour and our physical health. Anxiety becomes a problem when its level rises above normal and interfere with a person’s life, associated physical symptoms include, trembling, tense muscles, churning stomach, nausea, diarrhoea, headache, heart palpitations, pins and needles, sweating or flushing (Chrysalis 2010 1-5 pp7). These feelings coupled with the physical symptoms experienced make a person want
This condition has a considerable effect on Melvin’s life, not only do these numerous compulsive behaviors take up a lot of time in his life, the reactions that he’s, including his disregard for others and the insults that he throws at people portray him as a mean and stubborn man; which leaves him quite lonely with no friends. Melvin sought treatment into his disorder from a psychiatrist, for which he was prescribed medication to help him. He finds it hard to take the medication, which is in pill form, again an unrealistic worry that he will choke on the pill or not be able to swallow it, and subsequently die from the whole ordeal. Melvin is not a very open person about his disorder; he seemingly finds it hard to talk about what it really is that makes him do and say the things that he does. Melvin does find motivation for his treatment in the form of love. He finds that it is easier to take his medication when he is in the company of Carol; the waitress that brings him is breakfast daily. The thought of being with her soothes Melvin’s need for the compulsions in his life; he is more at ease when he is with her. Melvin unknowingly at first does not feel the need to fulfill his compulsions when he forgets to lock his door, counting it five times, when he returns to his apartment one night. He also finds himself being able to do things, such as stepping on the lines and cracks in
In this movie, Melvin displayed many compulsions. When he comes back to his apartment he locks his door 5 times and turns on and off the lights 5 times. He also washes his hands with 2 new bars of soap each time he washes his hands. When he walks, he avoids stepping on any cracks. He also sometimes repeats words quietly after someone has said something. Instead of trusting one, his has two clocks side by side near his bed for an alarm. These are just a few examples of the many compulsions Melvin has. He always
assistance of the social support consisting of Carol, Simon, and Verdell, Melvin broke ritualistic behavior on multiple occasions. For example, after connecting with Verdell, Melvin could break the ritualistic routine at the restaurant and sit at a table which was not Melvin’s regular table. Furthermore, after Simon moved into Melvin’s apartment, Melvin completely forgot about checking the door. Also, Melvin could break the habit of avoiding the cracks in the sidewalk while walking with Carol. Therefore, through continuing a solid support system Melvin should respond with a continuation of a favorable prognosis.
In the film As Good as It Gets, Jack Nicholson plays the role of Melvin Udall, a successful writer, who is arrogant, rude and is diagnosed Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD). Throughout the film, he engages in repetitive behavior, such as hand washing, checking, repeating, and counting which he uses to neutralize his obsessive thoughts. The film represents the psychopathology of obsessive-compulsive disorder accurately, displaying Melvin’s struggle with his fear of contamination, obsession with being clean, having everything organized and his fear of doubt. However, the film does not focus on the form of treatment that helps Melvin with his obsessive-compulsive disorder.
Melvin has multiple obsessive thoughts that are combated with multiple compulsive behaviors as well. This is very common among individuals who have OCD. He lets his compulsive behaviors take over his life. One of his obsessions is his constant fear of contamination. Even in his own apartment, he can never truly relax and feel carefree. There’s always perfectly new bars of soap to use for the multiple times he washes his hands with scalding hot water or a shower that needs to be taken for an unusually long amount of time. Another obsession is his need for control. He has the same set schedule that he follows precisely every day. However, as his routine continuously gets disturbed, he becomes even more anxious and irritable. His last obsession is doubt in himself and everyone around him. He locks and unlocks doors at his apartment whenever he enters a room and never steps on a crack outside in fear of something bad happening in the future.
Melvin, from the very beginning of the film, exhibits clear symptoms of obsessive-compulsive disorder, likely promulgated through social anxiety and various phobias. Some of the reoccurring symptoms Melvin displays include: germaphobia and a fear of being touched, avoidance of cracked surfaces, and a complete organization of his belongings. His fear of germs seems to be a major driving force in his obsessive-compulsive disorder. He doesn’t appreciate people entering his living space or touching him. He washes his hands relentlessly. Additionally, he does not trust the silverware to properly clean, so he insists on using new plastic ware each time he eats.
“Anxiety is the signal of danger which mobilizes the human organism’s resources at all levels of functioning in the interests of conservation, defense, and self- preservation.” (Anxiety 1) If a person suffers from anxiety there is a major loss of control and then an attempt to regain that control because of a fear that they have. Anxiety disorders are one of the most frequently occurring mental disorders in the United States. However, anxiety disorders are not only found in the United States. They are found throughout the world. They just happen to be most predominating in the United States. In this paper, I will be discussing the generalized anxiety disorder and how if effects society today.
Melvin Udall, a writer, has obsessive compulsive disorder. He has a real hatred for his neighbor, Simon’s, dog. He is very organized, with everything placed perfectly. Melvin does not like to be bothered or touched by anyone, no matter what the reason may be. For Melvin, everything must be routine, and he will get anxiety if anything changes. After Simon got beat up, Melvin was “forced” by Frank to take in his dog to his home. This seemed to change Melvin’s life; he suddenly became a little more caring and got upset when he had to give the dog back. In fact, it bothered him so much, he went to talk to his therapist. When Carol was gone from work, he tracked her down to find out why and hired a private doctor to take care of her son, just so she would
In As Good as it Gets Jack Nicholson portrays Melvin Udall, a misanthropic author with Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD). Throughout the film, Melvin engages in ritualistic behaviors , compulsions that disrupt his personal and professional life. This movie representation of psychopathology accurately depicts the functional interference and distress associated with OCD; however, Melvin’s over-the-top eccentricities obscure the boundary between what is “quirky” and what is OCD. To clarify this distinction, I will explain Melvin’s OCD symptoms with a focus on differentiating them from his underlying personality traits.
In the film “As Good As it Gets,” Melvin is a character with obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD). He engages in routines and rituals and any disruption to those compulsive behaviors is grounds for complete chaos and panic in his life. Melvin struggles daily with the need to go to a certain restaurant and be waited on by the same waitress each time. He also has hand washing rituals and the need to lock the door constantly. These obsessions and compulsions are representative of OCD.
Melvin was self-oriented, who only cares about his own desires and needs, not others ‘feelings. For instance, when he entered the restaurant, he rudely told Carol that he is
Through a critical look at Melvin’s situation within the film, it is appropriate to identify that a new update is required to cover for the new DSM 5 version that is recently under consideration from the American Psychiatric Association (APA). While the DSM 4 version is appropriately placed to incorporate all language and subjects that are relevant for disease diagnosis and classification, the next version should be considerate of the evolution within the psychiatric platform to give room for update and inclusion of more information based on the changes in behavioral approach and diagnosis criteria (American Psychiatric Association, 2000). Melvin portrays the specific alteration within his eccentricities obscurity and behavior realized from OCD. To fully identify the difference between the anxiety behavior and incorporation of differential behavior, the new DSM needs to incorporate all description from various anxiety related behavior and personal approaches that are relevant for studies and professional research. Through this incorporation, the APA can easily enhance suitability within its operations as well as foster understandability within all sectors that are relevant for professional research and
1) In the movie as Good As It Gets, Jack Nicholson plays a character by the name of Melvin Udall, Single, maybe in his 50s lives alone, never married but a successful love novelist. Melvin demonstrated from the get-go traits of being homophobic, racist, self-centered, lacking empathy and social skills and unusual behaviors. As time goes on he witnesses the hardship of his neighbor Simon an artist and who falls into a depression, Carol a hopeless romantic with a sick son who he slowly starts feeling empathetic for. The “abnormal” behaviors that stuck out the most were his unusual Obsessions and Compulsions. Melvin had an obsession with being contaminated; he wore gloves to avoid touching things or people, or couldn’t wear a used coat and tie. There was a part in the movie were Melvin was using a pair of gloves and he threw them out, washed his hands with hot water, opened 3 new bars of soap to only wash his hands for 10 seconds at the most with each bar. In another scene Melvin was walking through a crowd of people and it looked like he was dancing but he was really trying to avoid all the cracks on the street. I saw hope in Melvin though when he was at the restaurant and a group of children were gathered around Verdell. Carol Connelly (Helen Hunt) mentioned “Aren’t you afraid he might get stolen”? Melvin moved from his usual table to move closer to keep an eye on verdell which was something out of his comfort zone which lead me to believe this was the first step in the