preview

Repressed Memory Case Study Examples

Decent Essays
Open Document

In July of 1988, the Michigan court of appeals was met with a difficult case, one that would set the precedent for many cases to come. Jan Meiers-Post came to the court to seek justice for the sexual abuse she endured as a teenager in high school. Her teacher, Robert Schafer had allegedly assaulted her multiple times from her sophomore year to her graduation in 1974. The case was originally dismissed but not for the usual reasons that one might expect. You see, Ms. Post had suffered from repressed memory and her case was based off of her retrieval of those memories after watching a television show that depicted a teacher assaulting his student. In previous cases, repressed memory cases were dismissed as the retrieval usually exceeded the 3-year statute of limitations that applies to personal injury. However, Mr. Schafer had admitted that a sexual relationship did develop in those years as Ms. Post had frequented his house to help with correcting papers. This provided corroborating evidence for the plaintiff’s case and the trial was permitted to proceed (Leagle, 2015). …show more content…

The scientific community battles over the legitimacy of the phenomenon and has yet to come to an absolute consensus. In the case above, three psychiatric professionals submitted statements and each provided vague answers to the question. The first, Dr. David Ihilevich, provided that such a phenomena was possible and did not offer any further opinions. Dr. Allan J. Enelow, the second, says that it was “probable” that Ms. Post could have repressed memory as a form of PTSD. However, he says that her mind could have been influenced by the TV program to shape the memories that resurfaced. The final opinion of Joan Brazelton, holding a Masters’ in Social Work, also accepts the possibility of repressed memory, but offers an ambiguous opinion on the actuality of those memories (Leagle,

Get Access