preview

Repression In Psychology

Decent Essays
Open Document

Do all memories hold the same value in one’s mind? Certainly the memory of last year’s history test does not carry the same significance as the memory of a traumatic event of the past. In either case, the memory can be lost; however, the process in which this takes place has been a crucial question in the debate between repression and ordinary forgetting. The controversy over manners involved in forgetting traumatic events has generated powerful discussions between experts in the field of psychology. The phenomenon of repression has been researched and expanded upon from Sigmund Freud’s views in 1915 by the recent works of Jennifer Freyd, Dennis Bull, and Linda Williams. Their position on the matter is consistent with the notion that there …show more content…

The first and most striking bit of evidence for dissociation out of William’s study is that out of 129 women with documented cases of sexual abuse, 38 percent had no recollection of the abuse 17 years later (Williams, 1994, p. 1167). The fact that the 129 cases were reported to a city hospital at the time the abuse occurred gives validity to the research because it takes the false memory debate out of the picture. As Williams (1994) stated, “The finding that such a high proportion, 38% of the women, did not tell the interviewer about the child sexual abuse that was documented in the hospital records from the 1970s was quite dramatic…this is a significant proportion of the sample” (p. 1170). Some may argue that this number could be flawed due to the possibility that some women did not want to tell the interviewer about the abuse; however, as stated by Williams (1994), “although some of these women may have simply decided not to tell the interviewers about the abuse, additional findings discussed later suggest that the majority of these women actually did not remember the abuse” (p. 1170). These additional findings include the willingness of subjects to disclose many other personal matters to their interviewer, including other experiences of childhood sexual or physical abuse; in fact, 68 percent of the women who did not recall the documented abuse reported other sexual assaults (Williams, 1994, p. 1170). The second piece of evidence for repression introduces a new support in line with Fryed’s theory of betrayal trauma, which is that recollection is higher in cases where the sexual abuse was committed by someone they

Get Access