Critical Analysis of a Quantitative Study
Introduction
Research analyzing is a process in which a research undergoes a careful examination for its strength and weakness. Analyzing a research gives the nurse a chance to know the credibility of the study, its findings to see the evidence base for practice or utilization or application of the findings into the care practice. This paper is about analysis of a research conducted in relation to wound care in primary health care. This research took place in Stockholm, Sweden. The study shows a descriptive quantitative approach in investigating district nurse wound care management.
Protection of Human Participants
For this study district nurses (DNs) working at primary health care centers
…show more content…
Data collection was from the questionnaire that consisted of questions related to experience background, training for wound and wound care, responsibilities and in regards to wound care guidelines, including the wound registration form. This was collected in Monday through Friday within a week.
Data Management and Analysis
The data collected from questionnaire and registration forms were computerized and processed using the calculation program excel. The results were in a descriptive manner with numbers and percentages. The questions with open reply were analyzed by theme analysis. The results obtained were extracts of statements presented by the district nurses (Friman, Klang & Ebbeskog, 2010). Three researchers were involved in data collection , all data collected were transcribed exactly same as it was in the questionnaire, read and categorized according to what appeared from the data, this helped in minimizing researcher bias.
Findings / Interpretation of Findings
As per the researchers findings district nurses treated many kinds of wounds, but most often without proper medical diagnosis. There was no officially defined area of responsibility of the different professional groups. There was no proper wound treatment guidelines found most of the time.
Wound management is one of the cornerstones for nursing care however, effective wound care extends far beyond the application of the wound itself. Nurses may be required to assess, plan, implement, and evaluate wound care; therefore, order to fill these roles it’s critical to have an understanding of the several different areas of wound care such as, integumentary system, classification of wounds, wound procedures, and documentation. Knowledge in each of these areas will allow nurses to make well informed decisions about wound care, and as a result play an active part in wound healing.
Choosing of this dissertation among ED staff especially AMO so that they will be able to perform the procedure correctly, safely and practice according to current research based recommendations, to ensure effectiveness and patient safely. Cases of wound infection from T&S procedure can be reduced and increase patients trust in the provided services. Staff will be able to implement the procedures properly and safe in accordance with the recommendation, based on studies of wound infection from the patients.
I showed the supernumerary nurse the proper way of preparing an NPWT using a non-touch sterile technique, started by slowly cleaning the surrounding skin prior to the application of the pressure dressing. Since it was the first time of the preceptee to perform a pressure dressing, I have provided my preceptee the principles of wound management so that it will reinforce the knowledge of the supervised nurse and skills on the management of wound using NPWT. I also provided the preceptee the protocols and the wound management chart to take note of the type of solutions to be used in managing a surgical wound. We also documented in the progress notes what we have performed, and informed the nurse in-charge on the frequency of dressing change in a week.
The issue at hand has already been identified as wound care teams being a main key in the prevention and the expensive and extensive treatment of pressure ulcers. Since the research at hand is in need of additions, this project hopes to implement new information. We would aim to conduct
On assessment, the wound was slightly exudates, odour, sloughs and dry skin patches on the surroundings. Sprakes (2010) state that, holistic assessment of patient and the wound are essential in order to facilitate the wound healing process. Ousey and McIntosh (2010) points out that, chronic wounds are exacerbated by a sequence of misdiagnosis, neglect, incompetence or inappropriate treatment strategies. I observed that, M’s wound was with exudates and sloughs; this
Cobb, D.K., Warner, D. (2004). Avoiding malpractice: the role of proper nutrition and wound management. _Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, 5_ (4 Suppl), H11-6. Retrieved April 14, 2006, from OVID MEDLINE database.
The qualitative research article selected for critique is the study by Athlin et al. (2009), with the title of, “Factors of importance to the development of pressure ulcers in the care trajectory: perceptions of hospital and community care nurses”. This study looked at contributing factors promoting the growth or relapse of pressure ulcers, and how the nurses working in hospitals or group care, comprehend them in the care trajectory.
A full assessment of the wound should be carried out prior to selection of dressings. Any allergies should also be noted. The wound should be traced, photographed and measured providing data for comparison throughout the treatment. Consent should be gained prior to photographing the wound and the patient should not be identifiable from the photograph (Benbow 2004). All information should be documented in patients’ records, using the wound assessment tool. The pressure sore was identified as grade two
Researchers will decide to select wound infections that occur after open heart surgery as a topic for their study, because it is significant for staff nurses to know the effect of wound infections that occurs with the adult patients. Researchers will obtain permission from the cardiac surgery center so that they could collect information from adult patients. They will also contact and meet with staff nurses in cardiac surgery center. Nurse educators will provide the form to all staff nurses working in the operating room. The form includes the title of the study, the purpose of the study, place of the work, duration of the study, potential benefits, potential risks, participant signature, and date. The reader can follow that consent
This paper will address and evaluate the research problem itself, the design of the study, the sample, how the data is collected, its limitations, and its findings. Furthermore, how does this study impact the overall nursing process?
A wound can be described as damage to an area of the body, it can be internal or external, external wounds are damages that affect the skin and the anatomy of the skin. It is named by the type of forces that caused them. This essay briefly describes the current state of wound care in Canada, and also the projection wound care in Canada in the next 10 years. In order to understand where we are, we need to reflect on the genesis of wound care practice in
The first couple of paragraphs include an explanation of what is considered a complex wound and the current available treatments. It is beneficial that the authors include an explanation of what the problem is so that the reader can have a better understanding of why this issue is of concern. The paragraphs then transition towards the types of treatments available for the problem and a description of why the current treatments are not sufficient for restorative care.
The critique a quantitative nursing research study at the level of understanding and analysis, practically do not exist, but the researchers had to be selected in accordance with the results of training, the level of development of their self-study skills before the research and its results. It would be desirable to compare a pool of the data on patients before research and after .
There are three authors for this quantitative research study. Martin Knoll is the HTW of Saarland, Clinical Nursing Research and Evaluation, Saarbruecken, Germany. Christine Lautenschlaeger, Institute of Medical Epidemiology, Biometry and Medical Informatics, Martin Luther University of Halle-Wittenberg, Germany is the second author. And last, Marianne
In this assignment I will be writing about the importance of research in nursing considering history of nursing and the difference between how research is performed nowadays. I will also be defining different types of research such as quantitative and qualitative research and giving an example of a nursing based research study that was carried out and how it is important to nursing presently.