preview

Responsible Evil Essay

Decent Essays

The creation of the idea of ‘responsible evil’ discussed in the first of essay of GM appears therefore to be at the origin of Christian concepts and values of ‘good’, ‘bad’ and ‘evil’ that are still dominant in mentalities to date. In fact, although its consequences affect the slave morality as a whole, it seems that the creation of ‘responsible evil’ is most of all the one of priests . This supports the idea that the successful creation of ‘responsible evil’ has resulted in a spread of Christian influence and authority that still exists in modern societies. What is more, this slave’s invention is at the origin of the concepts of ‘guilt’, ‘bad conscience’, ‘mercy’, and of a God “that commands them [the slaves] to do and be what their weakness requires them to do and be” . In this way, with …show more content…

Yet, one can argue that the slave’s invention of ‘responsible evil’ is the result of a questionable syllogism that slaves use to affirm and define themselves in relation to the morality and identity of the strong. The “I am good, therefore you are evil”, “You are evil, therefore I am good” slave’s concept lacks of evidence, and does not make sense like the master’s conception of ‘good’ and ‘bad’ originally did. Thus one could as well argue that blaming the master of being evil does not prevent in any way the slave to remain bad, despite his conviction that he becomes good because the master no longer is. It also seems to be Nietzsche’s point of view, as he asserts that priests are ‘dishonest’ and ‘untruthful’ individuals turned into “the greatest and most ingenious haters” (GM, I.7) by their initial state of powerlessness, and whose only solution was to create a ‘spiritual revenge’

Get Access