preview

Rhetorical Analysis Of Designer Genes By Bill Mckiibben

Decent Essays

Designer Genes: Rhetorical Analysis Humanity is always trying to find a way to make themselves better. In recent news, this has led to a moral debate on weather or not using performance enhancing drugs for sports is morally correct or not. But, what if we had already manipulated the human body to make it better before we were even born? This is what Bill McKibben is referencing in his essay “Designer Genes”, on the morality and the biological arms race that could result when dealing with genetic manipulation and engineering. Though the cat isn’t out of the bag for genetic engineering he references what scientists are doing to skim the fine line that laws and ethics have laid down for us. McKibben’s audience is people who can make laws …show more content…

For example, in the essay it states, “It was one of those bad things measured in extinctions, as in ‘three tablespoons of botulism toxin could theoretically kill every human on earth’…had begun injecting dilute strains of the toxin into their brows” (McKibben 515). McKibben in this passage is using his own experience and wording to create a more powerful argument. He states that what people are using to make themselves look younger is a “toxin”, which creates the appeal that these substances are not good for the human body. Which he then rolls into the genetic engineering. Therefore, he is making a connection between the genetic engineering that is cropping up to the poison that we are already using. Which gives the allusion that we should not be meddling in substances which could be a detriment to our health and safety. Lastly, McKibben has his own initial and produced pathos within the writing. In his essay, he relates the genetic engineering to consumerism, and the future of global ecosystems. Which McKibben has written books and other essays on these topics such as, The End of Nature, and Enough: Staying Human in an Engineered Age. He also in his writing produces his own pathos. In the writing, he uses quotes from reputable sources such as March on Dimes organization, who fundraise and perform research to prevent birth defects and infant mortality. Which

Get Access