preview

Rhetorical Analysis Of `` Why I Write ``

Decent Essays

My topic in this writing will be whether or not Joan Didion’s piece gets the rhetorical devices through to her audience. The two main rhetorical elements I will be looking at are didactic and imagery, I will also look at how they either do or don 't work well. First off Joan Didion took the title from George Orwell because she liked the words or at least the sound of them. In her essay “Why I Write” she explains how she writes and how she became a writer using her own mental images. In a way, she is a visual learner. So with her using didactic and imagery in a way to explain how the word “I” is her voice, not an author 's voice. Overall she gives a good case for basically why you should use “I” sparingly. Her use of her own mental imagery was a great touch, it added a new dimension to it by not just assuming where she got it but actually telling us. Although I can see some issues on how it didn 't work as a strong convincing argument within the essay of hers, one of those being how in her third page she is giving examples. These examples of her writing without “I” is good, yet they don 't give a strong case for why you shouldn 't use “I”. Granted her before and after paragraphs give great quotes and a strong, clean reasoning why you shouldn 't. A saying so powerful as “It tells you. You don’t tell it” (Didion, 1976, p. 2), and as a follow-up we get the watered down examples, it just doesn 't live up to the first part. I guess it true even in writing, the first one is

Get Access