preview

Robert Altman's California Split

Decent Essays

In comparing an August, 1974 film review from The Great Speckled Bird with one from the New York Times from the same time period and regarding the same film, two very different styles of writing, and the thoughts of two very different kinds of writers are immediately found. The tone and language of the two reviews are vastly different, as is the review content for Robert Altman’s California Split (1974).
The Times article, written by Vincent Canby is an engaging, easy read that apparently appreciates the idea that if people are watching, then the film is worth critiquing. His writing is professionally brief, and intelligent on the surface, though he does come off as a bit of a wordsmith for hire. While it is true that the public does look …show more content…

The New York Times is generally acknowledged to have liberal leanings, but the language of the review is formulaic and its length comparable to several other film reviews read by this writer, leading to the idea that this is a “cookie cutter” format for the newspaper – after all, space is money for publishers.
Interestingly, neither of the reporters directed an artistic gaze to California Split, in spite of Altman’s tendency toward non-conformity in both his themes and directing style. No mention was made of the director’s habit of using destabilizing and sometimes insubordinate twists to intentionally express his personal vision, and this writer finds that remarkable considering the social, political, and cultural changes in the moment of 1974.
In that moment, the Middle East and the Soviet bloc were rapidly destabilizing. Nixon and the Watergate scandal brought impeachment proceedings into American homes, the prices of oil, gold, and silver were precipitously shifting, nuclear weaponry and the challenge of the arms race quickened, the racial mix of world culture and politics was shifting, fluorocarbons and ozone depletion became a reality, people of the world learned to dance and sing in new patterns and with new voices as the Beatles (among others) broke up and reimagined themselves, and the Episcopal church began the ordination of women

Get Access