preview

Rosencrantz And Guildenstern Are Dead: Play Comparison

Decent Essays
Open Document

Rachna Shah
5th Hour

Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead: Movie-Play Comparisons

One directorial invention was the movement of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. While the play did not specify whether the characters were moving, it was largely implied that they were stagnant. However, in the first coin toss scene in the movie, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern were riding on horses, rather than sitting. The inclusion of the horses further evokes a disoriented feeling in the viewer when the characters suddenly find themselves in Elsinore, rather than in the woods, as the horses are nowhere to be seen. Once at Elsinore, they are ordered to determine what afflicts Hamlet. Yet when they come across Hamlet, they do not attempt to engage in conversation …show more content…

the apple tree). Rosencrantz conducts the feather-ball experiment to show that the feather and ball fall at different rates. The laws of gravity dictate that the ball will fall first. However, when this very logical event actually happens, Rosencrantz is surprised. In much the same way, when Rosencrantz comes across a makeshift pendulum in the garden, he is astonished by the law of the conservation of energy. Newton represents the very essence of logic and reason. By not being able to comprehend logical principles, the director underscores Rosencrantz’s unworldliness and naivete. While Rosencrantz is able to grasp the basic of logical ideas, when he tries to convey them to Guildenstern, he fails. He is able to get a glimpse of the truth. For instance, for a moment he understands that objects should fall at the same rate regardless of their mass. Similarly, by swinging the pot back too far, the pot breaks, and Newton’s cradle breaks-he then seems to assume that the conservation of energy does not hold true. He unintentionally dismantles the logic he instinctively knows to be true. The references to Newtonian physics create an imbalance between what we know to be true - the laws of nature - and our misunderstandings of these truths. In the movie, this imbalance is accentuated to an absurd extent. While Rosencrantz understands the truth, after a brief second, he loses it - his distraction-prone nature

Get Access