preview

School-Based Interventions

Decent Essays

Studies on school-based interventions have identified programs as being effective when they are implemented by teachers, mental health professionals, and trained interventionists, however, there is little agreement on which leaders implement programs most effectively. One literature review revealed that of 49 school-based mental health interventions, teachers were involved in implementation 40.8% of the time and were the sole providers of the intervention 18.4% of the time. The majority of the more intensive, targeted interventions were provided health professionals (Franklin, Kim, Ryan, Kelly, & Montgomery, 2012).
Durlak et al. (2011) performed a meta-analysis of SEL intervention studies, which revealed that teachers and other school staff …show more content…

However, the sustainability of teacher-led programs can be hindered by unseen obstacles, such as lack of support from school administrators, inadequate teacher training, teacher burnout, and teachers’ feelings of lack of self-efficacy (Han & Weiss, 2015). Han and Weiss (2015) assert that school-based programs are more sustainable when they are acceptable to school administrators and teachers, supported by empirical evidence, practical to implement on a regular basis, and adaptable to individual circumstances. Another obstacle to the efficacy and sustainability of interventions is the reality that many teachers feel inadequately prepared to address student’s mental health needs (Rothì, Leavey, & Best, 2008). In a study by Rothì et al. (2008), several teachers stated that they would value training by a mental health professional on how to better support children’s mental health …show more content…

In their meta-analysis, Stice, Shaw, Bohon, Marti, and Rohode (2009) found that when professional interventionists led school-based depression prevention programs, children showed more significant and more sustained effects at follow-ups than interventions led by teachers. Stice et al. (2009) assert that professional interventionists are capable of providing more efficacious interventions because of their superior training, increased supervision, and greater allotment of time that can be devoted to providing interventions, as compared to teachers. This reinforces the previously discussed conclusion that mental health prevention program leaders require more training than teachers typically receive to effectively implement programs. Stallard et al. (2014) performed a randomized controlled trial of 45 schools to examine whether the effectiveness of an anxiety prevention program for children ages 9-10 was moderated by whether the program was implemented by a teacher and school staff member or by professional interventionists. The teachers and staff members who delivered the program were trained and had ongoing supervision. They found that despite the training that teachers received, there was a greater reduction in anxiety symptoms among the children who participated in the groups led by the trained facilitators (Stallard et al.,

Get Access