School Choice Argument Paper
Client’s Name
Institutional Affiliation
As an American taxpayer I personally agree with school choice as I studied at a public school and understand the differences between public and private education. Parents should be able to use these state-issued debit cards to decide which type of educational institution they want to send their child to. The counterargument to this is that taxpayers’ money is going back into the private trust rather than into the public school institution. School choice means providing this funding for low income students who live in school zones with lower quality schools. If a family can, with these state-issued cards, send their child to private school, then they should be able to do so as it provides a great opportunity for advancement. In this regard, school choice is a “vehicle to help improve inner cities and to provide options particularly for low-income families trapped in failing schools” (Swaby). However, any person in charge of the education system, especially the newly appointed Betsy DeVos, should have a very extensive background in education and should have
…show more content…
However, not all of them have a history in education, and while this can bring diversity and different perspectives into an educational board, it simply doesn’t seem right that they are controlling educational services if they have little to no hands-on experience with the institutions they are governing. Stricter qualifications should be required for any person looking to hold office in an educational institution just in the same way that doctors are required to complete residencies in their field before performing medical work and lawyers are required additional training before practicing
One of the most crucial parts of education is qualified and enthusiastic teachers who are willing to dedicate their time. Would Aristotle have revolutionized philosophy if he was not taught by Plato? And would Plato have done the same if he was not a student of Socrates? Educators who are hired in the Appoquinimink School District appear to be hired simply because of their qualifications, not because they are passionate about teaching. Specifically, a teacher last week refused to teach the required material and called me “cranky”, and the week before that an Advanced Placement Language and Composition teacher said to me “maybe if you participated in class more, people would like you better.” Although both teachers have a Master’s degree, they clearly act unprofessional which ultimately affects my learning experience. Emerson describes the modern educational system and compares it to how teachers should be, “Hence the instruction seems to require skillful tutors, of accurate and systematic
Would you believe me if I told you that the person who is in charge of all the schools in the country isn't even qualified to be a superintendent, principal, or even a teacher? Well, it’s true. The presidential nominee and now approved Secretary of Education, Betsy DeVos, is not fit for this position. Although the DeVos family has provided many jobs for Michigan families with their businesses, this job should have been given to someone who has experience in the education field.
One part of her being unqualified for the position includes her vast inexperience. This causes people to question her authority as Secretary of Education. The DeVos’ have only attended private schools for their education. By only attending private schools, she does not understand the struggles
In the 1950’s the school choice debate came to view education as a service that could be produced in a variety of ways and that parents could be consumers of (Musset, 2012). Musset’s research explored the idea that schools would be judged based on performance, being rewarded with expansion as families choose them over those schools who do not, while those underperforming schools would lose funding as families vote with their feet as they withdraw their children from those schools (2012). Over the last half-century the research, including that of Duncan(2007), has come to include the performance of private schools as they collectively outperformed public schools amongst the lower-socioeconomic and minority populations of the United
Finally and foremost, school districts need to get rid of tenure. It is absolutely insane to allow a teacher to have absolute job security no matter how badly they perform. If a teacher can teach they will always have a job. Tenure does not protect high performing teachers as it was intended to do instead it protects low performing teachers. This is vital in getting rid of horrible teachers like Mrs. Eicher who is immune to job loss as a result of how long they have worked at the school.
In the United States, public schools get their funding from their respective state. As a student, it can be seen as concerning when one compares how much states spend on their schools. Many schools are inadequate in both an aspect of safety and effectiveness of the learning environment. As a result of inadequate subsidy across America, schools resort to taking drastic measures. Not only are the unequal sources of subsidy a difficulty, but the concept and execution of budget cuts also exacerbate the issue. In order to give every student in America equal opportunities for success, funding should be controlled by the federal government with a policy that enforces equity rather than equality. This is also a viable option that could be carried
Public School Choice -Students may go to any public school in their surrounding district this giving a better chance to receive a more adequate education
Since the emancipation of slavery, the African Americans had a continuous fight for their complete emancipations and for their civil rights for over one hundred years. The white Americans couldn’t accept and see the African Americans as free human being and equal as them. Their ignorance was making them blind, building in themselves a hate that was unbearable to a human kind to do to the others. That hate overcome any reasonable behave that forced the law to intervene several times for consecutive years.
Therefore, the schools don’t have enough money to give out a good curriculum for teaching. A great education is critical in today’s society a person needs at least some type of college degree to get a decent
In the future there will be problems with poverty because that is an issue that will never die out no matter how many acts are created. There will always be problems with diversity, but, with the Department's hard work they will be able to help as much as they can and hopefully the future will look brighter overall for the Education system in the United States. But, with elections coming up this year there might be a change with the Department of Education. There is a fact that at least one candidate wants to decrease the Department of Education size. If that were to happen then there could be an even more decrease in the support of Education and our system could very well become weaker. We need to keep this Department in the cabinet so there is a chance of improvement in the
One of the biggest arguments for vouchers is that they allow parents to choose what school is right for their child. Parents, in taxes, pay for their children’s education, and they should be able to send their children where they want with their education dollars. These vouchers also allow for the parent to decide what school is best fitting for their child based on their racial, cultural, and religious background. A second argument in favor of the school voucher is that, “Advocates believe that vouchers promote fairness, participatory democracy, and engagement with public debate as well as improved quality of education” (Hochschild & Scovronick, 125). Parents who are unable to afford homes in more prominent neighborhoods are forced to send their children to failing districts because they are unable to afford the tuition costs of private schools. If the voucher program was being used, then lower-class parents would have the opportunity to use their own tax dollars to send their children to a more prominent school.
As standardized test scores continue to plummet and our nation falls farther behind such industrial rivals as Germany, England, Australia and Japan in comparable education, parents are questioning the current system of education. After being kicked around the national agenda for decades, the school voucher issue is finally being emphasized in several state legislatures, as well as in Congress. In the website titled "Vouchers: No, but...Taxpayer Help to Parents will Advance Separation", David Bahurlich reinforces his support of school vouchers, both publicly and privately funded, in an attempt to show that vouchers will lead to a better quality of education for the children in our school system
Charter schools are described to be a unique public school that offers an alternative education outside of traditional public schools in the Unites States. Charter schools are usually created by a group of people – parents, educators, community leaders- who come together and create a charter plan which explains the schools guiding principles, course curriculum, and so on. Once that charter is approved by the state, the state continues to fund the charter schools. “In the early 1990s, a small group of educators and policymakers came together to develop the charter school model. Minnesota’s legislature passed the first charter law in 1991, and the first charter school opened in 1992.”
Everyone needs to go to school. As children grow, parents must decide what to do about schooling. The options include homeschooling or sending the children to a private or a public school. Few choose homeschooling, most pick between sending their children to either a private or a public school. This choice affects the economy more than the student. The argument ‘If You Send Your Kid to Private School, You Are a Bad Person’ by Allison Benedikt, argues that sending children to private schools ruins trying to get what’s best for the children. Benedikt’s piece uses premises, and personal testimonies, but overall the argument she presents is weak.
Education is the foundation to secure an individual in having a better future and a successful career in life. Public education primarily falls upon the state and local government to take charge of, which get divided up into local school districts that are managed by school boards. School boards are “ an elected body corporate which manages delegated powers in regards to the deliver of education service within a defined territory (Duhaime’s Law Dictionary)”. Each state “has its own department of education and laws regulating finance, the hiring of school personnel, student attendance, and curriculum (Corsi-Bunker, Antonella).