preview

Second Degree Murder Case Study

Decent Essays

This Law and Order episode brings up an interesting question as to how far corporations are responsible for how their products are used. After fifteen women are killed in a shooting using a gun that is easily converted from semi-automatic to full automatic, McCoy tries to convict the gun manufacturer, Rolfe Firearms. I don’t believe Rolfe Firearms was guilty of Second Degree Murder. While trying to convict Dennis Trope, the man who committed the murders, the police asked Rolfe Firearms for the detailed specs on their gun. They refused saying it would give away trade secrets. I don’t believe corporations have a civic duty to cooperate with criminal prosecutions. Giving away company secrets could give the edge to their competitors and I don’t think corporations should be required to make their business vulnerable. Corporations have the right to protect business. Although Corporations might have a moral duty to cooperate with criminal prosecutions, it’s their decision if they want to potentially put their business at risk to help in a criminal prosecution. …show more content…

I don’t think it’s reasonable to require them to redesign the product, no matter how much it would potentially cost. All corporations are responsible for designing and selling their own products. The designs of the product is up to the corporation and shouldn’t be required to be altered. A private company shouldn’t be required to redesign their product just because someone thinks they should. No one should have the power to tell corporations how to make their products, as long as they are designed within the current laws. If the government is allowed to tell a gun manufacturer how to design their product, then they can tell anyone how to design their product, and that just doesn’t make

Get Access