preview

Shoeless Joe Research Paper

Satisfactory Essays

In observing various sports stories there can be distinguished approaches on how the story is told. The one distinction is realism vs romanticism. The main discrepancies in these approaches are that a realistic approach manifests the characters as ordinary people, the plot is developed around ordinary events/circumstances, the ending has the possibility of being unhappy, and the literature/film revolves around recent or contemporary life. On the romanticism side, the characters can be larger than life, the plot is developed around unusual events, the literature/film revolves around history or legend. We can see this distinction at work about the same character but in two different stories. This character is Shoeless Joe Jackson and the films …show more content…

The reason why is that the character Joe resembles an ordinary person. He doesn't appear or live in a fictional way. Unlike in the movie field of dreams, it is considered more of a romantic view of Shoeless Joe. He appears in a fictional way in what I consider a ghost version of himself. Secondly, the ending in 8 men out it is considered realistic because the ending is unhappy which is habitually the case of realism. In 8 men out Joe is banned from ever playing in the MLB. On the other hand in the Field of Dream is ending is happy with the Joe having the opportunity to play the game of baseball one last time.
In 8 Men Out the plot is also harmonious with realism. The plot revolves around players who get fed up with the poor treatment by the manager and decided to throw the game for profit. All of this is realistic. While in the Field of Dreams the plot contains more unusual events such as hearing voices, to Ray playing with a younger version of his father towards the end. Additionally, the language in 8 Men outfits in with the version of realism having ordinary speech while the language in the Field of Dreams has more of a romanticism approach with it become more literature and inflated.

Get Access