Should The Government Have The Enumerated Powers Of The Federal Government

In the early 1970s, the US knew that they needed a change in federalism so they called it new federalism. New federalism gave the states some power while knowing that the federal government is the highest power. At this time, the state government regained some power. Richard Nixon started to support this type of federalism during his presidency, and every president since Nixon has continued to support new federalism.(Sparknotes Editors,Federalism,page 1)

In the United States Constitution it is stated that “No single section of the constitution deals with federalism. Instead, the provisions dividing power between the states and the national government appear throughout the constitution. Most of the constitution is concerned with establishing the powers of the national government. National power is also based on the supremacy clause of article VI, which says that the constitution and laws made in accordance with it are “the supreme law of the land”. This means that when national and state laws conflict, the national laws will be followed. Article I, section 9 limits the power of the national government over individuals. The tenth amendment the constitution also limits the state powers in Article I, section10 and denies the states certain powers” (Keeping the

From 1789 to 1937, most fundamental powers were distinctive between the federal and state governments. The main problem with dual federalism was that states did most of the governing, and the federal government could only do tasks that were explicitly stated in the constitution.

One reason I believe the states should have the power to do what they think is best for their states right now was because these official are in this state and know what the people want and what they need in the state. See these political offical hear what the people want unlike right now the government tries to do what is best for all the people but some of it affects other states. If the states had the power to decide then all the states would be better and more prosperous. There have been case where the federal government has bullied the states into changing their mind to what they want. Such as in Louisiana they officials wanted to change the legal; drinking age to 18 years old because it

The relationship between the Federal government and the states is well stable. The Federal government has powers given by the Constitution as well powers or privileges are given to the states which promotes a balance between the two so that our country is not ruled under one specific party or group. The question now is that, are the states rights more than well protected in the current constitution and the political practice.

Federalism was the first guard against tyranny. The central government and states both had their own powers but also shared a few. They had trading, conducting foreign relations, declaring war, making immigration laws etc. Local state governments got elections, establishing schools, passing marriage and divorce laws, and regulating in-state business. “The different governments will control each other and at the same time it will be controlled by itself,” said James Madison in the federalist paper #51.

Ever since 1776, when the United States first gained independence, there has been constant debate over how much power states should have compared to the the federal government. Some argue that the central government should have more power, claiming when laws are uniform to every state, they will be more effective. Others, however, argue that if the states have more power that the federal government, then they can enact laws that will address the unique needs of constituents of that particular state.

The state government system is the bottom, the foundation of United States. Then, it moves up into the federal government which is at the top of the power chain. This whole concept shows that the state and federal government must have some the same policies and systems to work together, the way it does. Although, It must be somewhat different, otherwise a compromise would have never been made at the Constitutional Convention. Overall, this shows that the United States government gets all of its power from the citizens of the United States of

The State governments mostly have powers that can affect within their state, meaning their powers mostly affect their state. For instance, one of their powers are to regulate trade, but only within their state, again regulating trade is just making laws so that trading laws aren't unfair if they are. Furthermore, they also have the power to conduct elections (Chapter 4, The Constitution, pg. 222). To add on, they are allowed to form voting events to elect a president, like how our states had an election on who should be president and our states voted for Trump. Now our new president is Trump, States are allowed to form these events so that we do have a president. Another power that State governments have is the power to establish public school systems. In other words, they make the main layout of how public schools should work. The last power that State governments have is establishing local government

With the ratification of the United States Constitution, a new concept known as federalism was introduced. Federalism, as defined in the textbook, is “a system of government in which power is divided, by a constitution, between a central government and regional governments” (43). Basically, power is split between the states and the nation to make sure that they are kept in check. (47) The regional (state) government’s purpose was to decide how they wanted to handle their own issues that the national government did not already have limitations on. While the federal government’s powers would be based on the Constitution, limiting their power, compared to the states, whose powers would be more diverse. Many people were suspicious that the national

When considering the relationship between the federal government and the states as laid out in the original constitution, I believe it to be best described by James Madison in The Federalist # 45 when he states "the powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government, are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State

As said in James Madison’s Federalist paper, number 51, “In the compound republic of America, the power surrendered by the people is the first divided between two distinct governments, and the portion allotted to each subdivided among distinct and separate governments.” Some powers that were given to the Federal government is to regulate trade, declare war, and print and coin money. Some powers that were given to the State governments were to hold elections, establish schools, and pass marriage and divorce laws. By distributing powers between the Federal and State governments, neither can become tyrants, which means they will help keep each other in check. Federalism ensures that the Federal government doesn’t have too much say in what happens to the

The debate between who should hold more power; the state or federal government, has been debated and discussed since the inception of our nation. The original debate was centered on two opposing parties and their respective ideas, the Federalists and Anti-Federalists. Due to the numerous debates and shifting political climates, the powers have shifted between the states and federal government several times through the nation’s short history.

The concept of federalism came about as an answer to the failed confederation of states that existed following the Revolutionary War. Power, under the Articles of Confederation, was held primarily by the states, and the national government was made to be weaker than that of the states. This led to not only dissention between the states, as each tried to promote its own interests, but also to a national government that was too weak to provide essential services such as national security. In order to establish a national government that had adequate power and authority to perform its functions, while also maintaining rights of states to manage their own affairs, the framers of the US Constitution designed a federalist system, where power and

Over the years State powers has changed. The States have gained less power relative to the Federal government. Originally the States were the sole governing power through the Articles of the Confederation due to the fear of the development of a monarchy that the U.S. had fought so hard to rid themselves of. Thus gave creation a new form of government through the constitution which fundamentally began the shift of power from state to federal. Next, though significant historical events such as the New Deal and Civil Rights we will see the Federal government infringement on State power. Lastly, we will see how this constant struggle has continued to present day. First, let’s discuss how the constitution transferred State power to Federal power.