Is giving kids participation trophies beneficial to children, or motivation killers? Many people all around the U.S. have their opinions for both sides of the discussion. James Harrison, linebacker for the Pittsburgh Steelers, has weighed in on this topic. In many people’s eyes, his beliefs make a lot of sense, they understand where he’s coming from and what he is speaking about. Carol Dweck also made a statement to NPR about her belief’s on the topic. There are millions of important facts that need to be talked about with this epidemic: an estimated fifty-seven percent said “only winners” should receive a trophy for participation in kids sports, giving out participation trophies is tantamount to giving kids the wrong kind of praise, and this …show more content…
These kids are a cancer to teams. Everyone knows that there are always kids with bad attitudes that do not care; therefore, kids that act like this do not deserve to have a participation trophy. They do not care about the team and some of them are very impertinent. There are even some people that are there because their parents force them to play. There parents may have been really good athletes, but their kids are not always the best. Those kids are not respectful to the team, so why should they get a trophy for that?
Finally, kids that are given participation trophies are given the wrong idea. Fifty-seven percent of people said "only winners" deserve to have participation trophies, giving out participation trophies is tantamount to giving kids the wrong praise, and giving kids with bad attitudes and not a care in the world is not a good idea. These kids need to realize that they need
to earn things that are given to them. James Harrison had every right to take those trophies away from his kids. He is making those kids want to work harder and strive to earn a real trophy one day. Maybe one day they will end up like him and win a super bowl. That is when they are able to be given a trophy. When kids try their hardest and earn these trophies, that is when they should be
As Abate says, “children today need as much of that as they can get in our society.” Parker says trophy’s and not receiving one yourself can be degrading. In addition to acknowledging their effort, they also receive trophies or certificates, reminding them that they were a part of the
Participation trophies send a dangerous message. I have many trophies,but i worked hard for these trophies. Everyone on my team deserves my team. For the people who think giving out the same award at the end of the year to all the children; i am sorry to inform you that your hurting the child more than not giving the child the trophy at all. Children need to know the importance of working hard than someone else. In life you do not make the same amount as your boss makes just because you show up on time everyday. Why would the kids who just show up to practice everyday vs the kids the more elite kids get the same reward. Life does not work like that.
Really all the trophies should go to the kids that actually do all the work. They should not just give the trophies to the kids that do nothing. Kids should not just get a trophy for just showing up and sitting on the bench the whole
Participation trophies only hurt kids. These trophies have been given out in many sports for decades but they do not mean much to older children. Something as simple as golden painted plastic will not keep a child playing for long after their first years. Children must also be taught how to compete early on. These trophies create a lack of competition in youth athletes and should not be given to children above the age of ten to help teach them life skills and to protect them from struggling in their future lives when they will have to compete for jobs.
Do we give children too many trophies? According to Bob cook a sports father of four, “when it comes to participation trophies in my experience kids know the score.” Therefore at the end of the day, a trophy for involvement is a gift, and children are aware. Based on the facts and anecdotal evidence we are not giving children too many trophies. These pieces of plastic are a source of memorabilia. In addition, the trophy does not reflect the kid’s attitude towards hard work.
In an age where everyone is expected to be recognized, there must be an understanding that the world does not progress by congratulating the “average.” I believe that giving participation trophies makes people stop competing; especially if the trophies are given at a very early age. For example, a team of small children have a terrible baseball season, but it’s okay! Because the coach gives out trophies to everyone. This in turn only teaches the child that no matter how bad life gets, they will always be rewarded. Participation trophies create future generations of entitled adults as seen by today’s generation. We need to reward kids that work hard for what they do for the sake of risk and reward. That is simply how progress is made in society. Yet I agree with one point made by the opposing side. I believe that participation should be recognized sometimes. Participation can teach kids that teamwork matters in every little aspect of society. Participation trophies should be eliminated but participation should still merely just be recognized with a pat on the back as said by Betty Berdan, a high school junior from Connecticut. Participation trophies overall hinder the growing and learning process of kids; whether it is through sports, or any other competitive involvement.
Support 2: My next reason why kids should not get participation trophies is that it challenges them to do their best. In many cases, some of the players on sports teams don't try their best but get rewarded for it. This creates a false reality because the rest of the players have worked hard to get to where they are. Trying your best even when you may not succeed at times is better than not trying at all.
Participation trophies can vary from sports to clubs to activities of any type. Many people believe these standard awards provide many benefits for children and their childhood growth. However, children today have become accustomed to receiving an item or prize regardless the outcome of their effort, which could potentially send an unhealthy message about achievement and diminish the value of the award.
All across America, you see the topic of “Should children be receiving participation trophies” being brought up. The idea that all kids should get some reward for being a part of the game and helping it grow. To some, it seems like an excellent idea, but to others not as much. For example, NFL linebacker James Harrison took his children 's participation trophies and gave them back to their coaches saying "EARN a real trophy." Other parents believe that their children deserve to be praised and want them to feel good for doing something they have worked hard. So which side is correct? Should we give our kids these trophies or not?
Should everyone get a trophy? shouldn't get participation trophies because they need to be earned.the more trophies we give out, the less each one means. Some people believe that trophies should only be given out only to the best. However, participation trophies may encourage kids to keep playing. Participation trophies need to be taken out of the system because they don't boast the kids moral and they should only give trophies to the best.
I don't know about you but I disagree with those parents. I believe that only certain children should get trophies. If every kid knows that they're gonna get a trophy then they won't work as hard as they should, but if kids know that only a certain amount of kids will get a trophy they will work harder and achieve more goals. Ashley Merryman states that when extracurricular activities start and you go to sign your child up ask the program organizers “ Which kids get awards?”
It is also a good thing to give trophy to kids because you can out a smile on their face and make them feel special. There are many reasons to support those that people and coaches should not just give trophies to kids
Kids should not get trophies just because they worked hard. They should be rewarded for their athleticness. Sports help teach kids it’s okay to lose, they can learn they are not always going to be the best, they can learn what it takes to become the best, and how to work harder. Although kids may work hard, not everyone should get a trophy just for showing up.
These peoples thoughts are that participation trophies don’t cause any harm. They believe that participation trophies should be given out, not to state that everyone's a winner, but to congratulate young athletes on their time and effort put forth to compete. At the same time, they also believe that there is nothing wrong with celebrating a child’s achievement with a trophy that will make them happy, but not leave a lasting effect on their life (Website #1). However, even though it doe congratulate them for their effort, it also tells them that they will always win. Many people say that these participation trophies won’t leave a lasting impact on a child’s life, but you never know, maybe that one little trophy will cause them to become full of themselfs and narcissistic. All I’m saying is that It’s fine to acknowledge a child’s achievements, but participation trophies don’t do that. They show kids that they don’t need to work hard to
Kids should not get a trophy for participating because giving trophies sends the wrong the message. In CNN it states that, "Having a child return the trophy compounds the idea that only being the best is good enough when in fact giving one's best should have that mantle."