Comparative Analysis - Shutter Island vs Insomnia Shutter Island and Insomnia are mystery thrillers which follow two detectives that are determined to solve the case using their own techniques. Shutter Island is a classic, old fashioned thriller directed by Martin Scorsese. The film is based in 1954 and follows a federal marshal and his partner as they investigate the escape of a prisoner from a mental facility. The federal Marshall suffers a series of hallucinations and distractions on his path to uncovering the truth. Insomnia also follows a pair of detectives that suffer their own set of distractions and hallucinations. The detectives are dispatched to a small northern town where the sun never sets to investigate a murder of a teenager. The movie also resembles a classic thriller film that is directed by Christopher Nolan. Both films rely on a build-up of suspense and tension to deliver a compelling story. There are quite distinct similarities and differences in both films that are portrayed in areas such as characterisation, cinematic effects and social issues. Shutter Island and Insomnia use stylistic features to unpack the theme of appearance versus reality and documents the effects of the psychological effects on the protagonists. Both films portray the common theme of appearance vs reality in different ways. Noticeable similarities and differences can be seen in the portrayal of social issues, cinematic techniques and characterisation. Shutter Island revolves around Teddy Daniels, the protagonist who is a US Marshall sent to investigate the disappearance of a prisoner from a mental asylum. The movie unfolds on shutter island where it is apparent that there is a mystery to be solved. The movie takes the viewers on a psychological trip through the mind of Teddy Daniels as he battles to find the missing prisoner. As he progresses further with his case he starts suffering hallucinations and distractions which deviate him from differentiating fantasy from reality. These hallucinations and distractions derive from the PTSD Teddy suffers from. Teddy re-experiences his time in army fighting the Nazi’s and his wife’s death which distract him from solving the case. Delving into Teddy’s mind showed an
“Analyse, evaluate and compare the techniques used to dim the horror of the real life events discussed in the novel The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas and the film Life is Beautiful.”
Rikki-Tikki-Tavi was one brave mongoose who had the courage to go up against the fiercest animals on the planet, Cobras. (Movie)(Kipling 143) The story took place in Segowlee Cantonment, India in a house’s garden where Darzy the bird and his wife, Chucundra the muskrat, and the deadly Cobras live. (Kipling 143) The Rikki-Tikki-Tavi was a mongoose who got washed away from his home and ended up with a new family. He would would end up coming across three snakes in the large garden and killing them. Cobras, are one of the most dangerous snakes in the world. You must be brave to fight a cobra if you are not you could be snatched up any moment. Nevertheless Rikki-Tikki-Tavi the book and the movie are the same story they have differences such as the Plot, characterization, and the conflict.
After watching Martin Scorseses much misunderstood Shutter Island for a second time I have decided to evaluate both the stories meandering plot and its profound themes. Shutter Island is truly a tragedy of how one man cannot accept his reality. This film involves a character played by Dicaprio, filled with guilt of the death of his wife and losing his grasp on what is real and what’s not. In Shutter Island we are led to believe that Leonardo Dicaprio is playing a U.S Marshall under the name of Teddy Daniels. Daniels along with his new partner Chuck (played by Mark Ruffalo) has been led to Shutter Island to investigate the mysterious vanishing of Rachel Solando. The films big twist is that Teddy is in fact a patient of the mental facility who murdered his wife after she drowned their three children in the lake.
The Alfred Hitchcock film; Vertigo is a narrative film that is a perfect example of a Hollywood Classical Film. I will be examining the following characteristics of the film Vertigo: 1)individual characters who act as casual agents, the main characters in Vertigo, 2)desire to reach to goals, 3)conflicts, 4)appointments, 5)deadlines, 6)James Stewart’s focus shifts and 7)Kim Novak’s characters drives the action in the film. Most of the film is viewed in the 3rd person, except for the reaction shots (point of view shot) which are seen through the eyes of the main character.(1st person) The film has a strong closure and uses continuity editing(180 degree rule). The stylistic (technical) film form of Vertigo makes the film much more
During the process of envisioning and designing a film, the director, production designer, and art director (in collaboration with the cinematographer) are concerned with several major spatial and temporal elements. These design elements punctuate and underscore the movement of figures within the frame, including the following: setting, lighting, costuming, makeup, and hairstyles. Choose a scene from movieclips.com. In a three to five page paper, (excluding the cover and reference pages) analyze the mise-en-scène
Horror films are a format of entertainment used to thrill, entice, and scare audiences for years, dating all the way back to the era of silent film. In the genre, there are many types of horror, which include expressionism, melodrama, film noir, and science fiction. For the following prose, the style of German Expressionism will be highlighted by contrasting a film from 1919, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari directed by Robert Wiene, with 2010 film Shutter Island directed by Martin Scorsese. The archetypal monster both films focus on is the beast within. Essentially, both films have very similar story lines, so much so that Shutter Island can almost be considered an updated remake of Caligari.
Shutter Island portrays multiple mental illnesses in the main character as well as in supporting characters. One might call it an abnormal psychology “goldmine.” It takes place at a water-bound psychiatric facility, Shutter Island, housing the criminally insane. The plot is about a man who refers to himself as Teddy. He believes he and his partner are detectives, on the island, to investigate the disappearance of a patient. He is also in search of a patient named Andrew Laeddis, who Teddy believes murdered his wife. The detective becomes paranoid that the facility is treating the patients unfairly and performing experimental lobotomies. The delusion goes on for several months, Teddy never realizing he is actually a patient, until he is brought back to reality at the climax of the movie. His delusion ends. He realizes he’s a patient for a very short amount of time before he goes back to believing he’s a detective. The delusion starts all over again. Throughout most of the film, viewers see his delusion as a reality, until the twist at the end when it is revealed that he is actually a patient.
In the cinematic films Juno directed by Jason Reitman, 2007 and The Limey directed by Steven Soderbergh, 1999 are both extremely different, but both have the same sense of drama in the movie with the certain lighting places and different angles that were shown. In each Cinema they had filmed the shots and lighting for many given reasons to show a bigger picture. Both movies have a lose and shows the before and after lose but each mood and mind is completely different. In this essay, I want to focus on the angles of the camera and the lighting and how they are the same and how they differ and how the show what real state of mind is occurring.
The movie Shutter Island has several parallels to the book Double Bind. Both the main characters in the book and the movie, Laurel Estabrook and Andrew Latius, are portrayed as people who are investigating a case about a patient that has a mental illness. At the end, it is revealed that Laurel and Andrew are actual patients being treated for their mental illnesses. However, at the end of Shutter Island, it is left a mystery whether or not Andrew is actually crazy.
Wes Anderson’s films are known for their unique, stylistic characteristics that culminate into an aura of cartoonish reality. His 2014 The Grand Budapest Hotel proves no different, a mystery solving comedy split into five separate narratives, each at a different point and place in time. One particular scene that scene where mise-en-scene analysis proves useful is the climax where Agatha acquires the painting Boy with Apple, and encounters Dmitri as well as Mr. Gustav and Zero. The staging and performance of the characters captures indicative facial expressions and body language that culminate into an overall sense of anxiety and urgency, costume hair and makeup that represent the characters and their nature, and the lighting and color that symbolize the mood and state of the characters.
I am reading Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane, I am on page 369, and I finished the book. The remaining half of my book is about Teddy and Chuck on a journey to find Andrew Laeddis, the killer of Teddy’s wife, and they check Ward C on the island and the lighthouse and there is no sign of him. Teddy and Chuck get past some obstacles in their journey to the lighthouse, Chuck gets lost, and Teddy tries to escape the island on the ferry. In the end, Teddy encounters Mr. Cawley in the lighthouse; it is revealed that Teddy has been on the Island for two years and Teddy’s real name is Andrew Laeddis. It is also revealed that Chuck has been Dr. Sheehan the whole time and Teddy is actually Rachel Laeddis’s husband. In this journal, I will be characterizing Teddy in the second half of the book and questioning why Dr. Sheehan would pretend to be Teddy’s partner, Chuck, the entire time.
In the film Brokeback Mountain, Jake Gyllenhaal’s character Jack Twist says in the film, “Brokeback got us good, don’t it?” This story and the motion picture tells us viewers about the importance of following your heart and that true love can be forbidden according to certain circumstances. Both the film and the story have similar yet different transformations throughout the whole story on how both characters develop and also the importance of the setting of the Brokeback Mountain and how it was the place that brought the two men together always. To start off, first what the story is about.
‘Shutter Island’ is a water-bound mental hospital, accommodating the criminally insane. The tale begins with a U.S. Marshal and ex-war veteran named Teddy Daniels and his partner Chuck Aule. Set during the early-mid 1950’s, they arrive on Shutter Island with the intent of investigating the case of the missing Rachael Solando; a patient residing in Ashcliffe Hospital who has inconspicuously disappeared from her locked room. She was committed to the hospital after murdering her three children and Teddy and Chuck go through many trials and tribulations in order to find Rachael and solve the mystery surrounding her disappearance. A former alcoholic, who is troubled by the recollections of his deceased wife and traumatic thoughts of his service in WWII, Teddy expresses his true motive of finding Andrew Laeddis, the man who Teddy claims murdered
The film ‘Cast Away’ directed by Robert Zemeckis, is set around FedEx worker Chuck Noland, who crash lands a plane in the ocean on a business flight. Chuck wakes up on a stranded island, to find that he is alone, and trapped. An important scene within the film is when Chuck opens the FedEx packages he collected when he first arrived on the island, and proceeds to open them to use the contents of the packages to help him create a fire, which is significant to the theme of survival. A variety of aspects such as camera techniques, lighting, symbolism, and sound usage all have an effect on how this scene shows important to the theme of ‘loneliness’ + ‘survival’.
Edward “Teddy” Daniels, a U.S. Marshal in 1954 is heading to Shutter Island - a remote island accessible only by boat, home to Ashecliffe, a secure psychiatric facility- with his newly assigned partner Chuck, to search for a missing patient. As Teddy looks more into the disappearance of the patient, strange things begin to happen all around him. After his partner’s disappearance, he then comes across a former doctor living in a cave on the side of the island, who tells Teddy that the doctors are performing experimental surgery in the island’s lighthouse. This causes Teddy to take precarious measures to investigate the lighthouse. Upon reaching the lighthouse, Teddy is met by the lead psychiatrist and his “missing” partner, and is told that this was an elaborate role-play, and that he suffered from mental illness following the death of his children and him murdering his own wife. Teddy comes back to reality as Andrew Laeddis and decides he cannot live with his reality.