preview

Similarities And Differences In The Movie 'Shutter Island'

Good Essays

Comparative Analysis - Shutter Island vs Insomnia Shutter Island and Insomnia are mystery thrillers which follow two detectives that are determined to solve the case using their own techniques. Shutter Island is a classic, old fashioned thriller directed by Martin Scorsese. The film is based in 1954 and follows a federal marshal and his partner as they investigate the escape of a prisoner from a mental facility. The federal Marshall suffers a series of hallucinations and distractions on his path to uncovering the truth. Insomnia also follows a pair of detectives that suffer their own set of distractions and hallucinations. The detectives are dispatched to a small northern town where the sun never sets to investigate a murder of a teenager. The movie also resembles a classic thriller film that is directed by Christopher Nolan. Both films rely on a build-up of suspense and tension to deliver a compelling story. There are quite distinct similarities and differences in both films that are portrayed in areas such as characterisation, cinematic effects and social issues. Shutter Island and Insomnia use stylistic features to unpack the theme of appearance versus reality and documents the effects of the psychological effects on the protagonists. Both films portray the common theme of appearance vs reality in different ways. Noticeable similarities and differences can be seen in the portrayal of social issues, cinematic techniques and characterisation. Shutter Island revolves around Teddy Daniels, the protagonist who is a US Marshall sent to investigate the disappearance of a prisoner from a mental asylum. The movie unfolds on shutter island where it is apparent that there is a mystery to be solved. The movie takes the viewers on a psychological trip through the mind of Teddy Daniels as he battles to find the missing prisoner. As he progresses further with his case he starts suffering hallucinations and distractions which deviate him from differentiating fantasy from reality. These hallucinations and distractions derive from the PTSD Teddy suffers from. Teddy re-experiences his time in army fighting the Nazi’s and his wife’s death which distract him from solving the case. Delving into Teddy’s mind showed an

Get Access