preview

Similarities Between Han China And Rome

Decent Essays

With powerful militaries, vast amounts of territory, and millions of people of diverse cultures and roles operating under an organized civil bureaucracy, the Han Dynasty and ancient Rome were truly empires of great power and influence in Afro-Eurasia between 300 BCE to 300 CE. While the methods of gaining the position of globalizing empires were similar for the two empires, the social obligations possessed by the people of various social classes differed for the empires, leading to contrasting perspectives towards the empires’ governments. ALTHOUGH THE HAN DYNASTY AND ANCIENT ROME WERE BOTH EMPIRES OF IMMENSE POWER, LAND, AND INFLUENCE SUSTAINED BY PEOPLE OF ALL SOCIAL CLASSES, THE SOCIAL EXPECTATIONS AND OBLIGATIONS OF THE RULERS, SOLDIERS, …show more content…

After witnessing the strict policies and rule of the Qin Dynasty, the emperors of the Han Dynasty began to base their rule upon Confucian ideals revolving around the mandate of heaven and the legitimization of the emperor’s rule. Jia Yi, a scholar of both the Qin and Han Dynasties and a witness of Empress Lu’s harsh ruling, stated that “It is said that in government, the people are in every way the root (base)… Thus the security of the state or its endangerment depends on them [the people].” Yi explains that the power and legitimacy of the government resided in the people, thus, emperors …show more content…

Whereas the expectation to serve in the military and fight for the empire was generally enforced upon soldiers of Han China through the urging of the state, this social responsibility was ingrained into Roman soldiers through a culture of warrior ethos. Although the Han Dynasty moved away from many of the strict Legalistic regulations and punishments of the Qin Dynasty, it still integrated some Legalist institutions into Confucian doctrine. One such convention was the expectation for commoners to serve as either farmers or warriors in order to support the state. As explained by Lord Shang, a prime minister of the Qin Dynasty in the mid-fourth century in The Book of Lord Shang, “The means whereby a country is made prosperous are agriculture and war… That is called “wearying the people.” Soldiers of the Han Dynasty served mainly due to the obligation enforced upon them by the government for the purpose of “wearying the people” – in other words, the Han government wanted to limit education and thought and limit the people to war and agriculture in order to limit possible rivalries and opposition to the government. Contrastingly, the warriors of the Roman Empire upheld a powerful warrior ethos that heightened their sense of honor and ultimately produced the immense power of the Roman army. As Polybius, a prominent historian of Roman society, explains,

Get Access