preview

Similarities Between Holden Caulfield And Dorian Gray

Decent Essays

Wilde Sentences Dorian Gray and Holden Caulfield are dynamically dissimilar; one is a young man trying to fall into his natural place of perfection in the upper class while the other is a boy attempting to find himself within the chaos of the world. Dorian has a main passion of becoming the perfect dandy and Holden is seeking out who he should become through the hectic city of New York. Both of these goals are plot driven but subliminally can seen through sentence structure as developed by Salinger and Wilde. Both authors make efforts to subliminally highlight the goals of their characters, but they do so differently; Wilde uses extravagant sentences and rich language while in contrast Salinger uses cruder sentences and vernacular: Wilde …show more content…

Holden delivers his own narrative; Salinger choices this because it also the reader into the mind of Holden and gives more of a protagonal focus. In his self-directed narrative, Holden often uses short, punchy words like “Boy” and “Hell” to get across a sense of angst. Salinger even directly address how often Holden says “Boy”. Holden says “ "Boy!" I said. I also say "Boy!" quite a lot. Partly because I have a lousy vocabulary and partly because I act quite young for my age sometimes”. Salinger chooses“edgy” vernacular for Holden to highlight his childlike tendencies; Holden blames his “lousy vocabulary” in order to ignore how he grasping on to childhood by not maturing the his daily colloquial …show more content…

Initially, there is a strong focus on each physical detail in a scene. Such is true when Dorian is being first introduced, there is a heavy focus on his beauty rather than his personhood, Lord Henry says, “Upon my word, Basil, I didn't know you were so vain; and I really can't see any resemblance between you, with your rugged strong face and your coal-black hair, and this young Adonis, who looks as if he was made out of ivory and rose-leaves.” Here Wilde chooses to delicately describe the beauty of Dorian in a positive light. He takes a lot of time to describe his beauty because this is Dorian’s best feature. In that moment Dorian is seen as perfect, so when he is not seen as perfect, Wilde chooses to use quick abbreviated text to deal with it. When James Vane confronts Dorian about the death of his sister Sibyl, it goes by in an instant. James addresses Dorian, "You wrecked the life of Sibyl Vane," was the answer, "and Sibyl Vane was my sister. She killed herself. I know it. I swore I would kill you in return. For years I have sought you. I had no clue, no trace.”. Here James is direct with Dorian; Wilde does not create detail in these remarks, he merely puts them there for the reader to address. This breakdown in language is showing how Dorian is flawed for not

Get Access