preview

Similarities Between The Necklace And The Gift Of The Magi

Decent Essays

Both Guy de Maupassant and O.Henry are two very recognized short story writers and they wrote respectively The Necklace and The Gift Of The Magi which are going to be compared in this text. In the Necklace, Mathilde, the protagonist, is a jealous, poor, unhappy person and she does not give values to thing that she has. She is married with a young guy that is poor two but is not jealous. Her biggest fear was becoming poor and it turns reality at the final of the story when she realizes that the necklace was fake. The Gift Of The Magi is a story centered on a young couple living in a small apartment located in New York. They are poor so they have to sell something to buy each other a christmas gift. At the end of the story, the couple realize that they do not need gifts. Both stories deal with young and poor couples who face in a objective and are surprised with a unexpected, ironic turn. The objective of this report is to establish clear differences between the short stories and to provide …show more content…

The two stories occur around the turn of the century. There are two young couples that are twain mid-low class. The stories end with a worse siuation than before, for example in the Necklace Mathilde has to work very hard and goes into a great debt justo to pay a diamond necklace that she lost. At the end, she realizes that the necklace was a fake and her biggest fear grow into reality when Mathilde becomes poorer than she was. In The Gift Of The Magi, a woman sells her hair to buy a silver chain for her husband`s clock whereas her husband buys a hair combs to his wife. At the end, the couple realize that they do not need gifts and the most important thing is the love between them. The woman loses her beautiful hair and the men loses his nifty watch just to learn that what matters is the love between the two. Both short stories bring a theme that is a valuable lesson to learn in

Get Access