Similarities Between The Quarrel Between Poetry And Philosophy

1565 Words7 Pages
The Quarrel Between Poetry and Philosophy in Republic

Abstract: Plato sternly expels poets and their poems when creating his ideal land in Republic. And Starting from Plato, the quarrel between poetry and philosophy has been through almost the entire history of western thoughts. By combing the viewpoints of Socrates, the protagonist of Plato’s Republic, this paper will analyze why classical philosophers side against traditional poets and discover Plato’s real purpose of such a deportation. The discussion of philosophy’s homology with poetry will also be included.
Keywords: Republic; poetry; philosophy Throughout the history of western thoughts, the quarrel between poetry and philosophy never ends. Plato blamed poetry, while his disciple
…show more content…
Anthropomorphism, a distinct feature of Greek mythology, is characterized as the similarity between gods and men, not only in appearance, but also in psychology, temperament and behavior. It shows the sharing of shape by gods and man, the social network of gods, the secularization of gods’ life and the destiny state of god beings. In poems such as Iliad and Odyssey, gods are described as fragile and temperamental as human, totally dominated by their desires and failing to sublimate from instinct into higher intellect. It is alluded to by Socrates as an act of arrogation. Socrates points out that injustice is well defended in such poems and they are very likely to induce or exacerbate chaos and corruption in the…show more content…
S. Eliot’s observation that philosophy and poetry are two different languages about the same world. Leo Strauss, teacher of Rosen, a classicist who specialized in classical political philosophy helped his student understand that there was an irreconcilable tension between these two languages as they are commonly conceived. But Rosen pointed out that Strauss’s own conception of philosophy was incapable of defending itself against the theory of poetry brought up by Nietzsche and
Open Document