Socrates on Gender Equality Regarding Ruling a City

811 Words3 Pages
In Book 5 of Plato Republic Socrates and Glaucon have discussed that both men and women could become a guardian of a city. Socrates argues that both male and females although different in respect, can both become guardians of a city, just as both could become something else. Socrates points out that the main difference between everyone is that some minds are meant to become a carpenter, while another person is destined to become a doctor. Socrates concludes that here is not a pursuit relevant to city management where it belongs to a man because he is a man or a woman because she is a woman. Equality needs to be promoted, and that women must be able to pursue their virtues, whatever they may be. In the midst of their discussion Socrates presents the possibility that it could be a mistake to assume men and women could do the same job, when they are different in nature. Socrates compares a bald man to a longhaired man and argues that one or the other does not become a doctor or carpenter based on their hair, but by their craft, (454d). Socrates concludes that although men are naturally better then women, there are no pursuits that are relevant to the guardianship of a city. There is no reason that a woman cannot run a city because she is a woman, or a man because he is a man, (456). Although Socrates has his formed opinion, he presents the idea of what an objector may create that would oppose his findings. If both men and women have distinct natures, how can they do
Show More
Related

  • The Between Men And Women Of The Guardian Class

    1970 Words  | 8 Pages

    Despite the arguments for equality given between men and women of the guardian class in The Republic, Plato didn’t offer a solid theory that liberated women in general. Book V within the Republic, deals with the status of women. This essay will show that Plato’s theory is not sustainable by assessing certain parts of his dialogue and offering insight on the subject of gender based on critical analysis and modern day perceptions. Before analyzing Plato’s arguments, its evident to note that women

    Read More

  • Library Management

    204752 Words  | 820 Pages

    Library and Information Center Management Recent Titles in Library and Information Science Text Series Library and Information Center Management, Sixth Edition Robert D. Stueart and Barbara B. Moran United States Government Information: Policies and Sources Peter Hernon, Harold C. Relyea, Robert E. Dugan, and Joan F. Cheverie Library Information Systems: From Library Automation to Distributed Information Access Solutions Thomas R. Kochtanek and Joseph R. Matthews The Complete Guide to Acquisitions

    Read More

More about Socrates on Gender Equality Regarding Ruling a City

Open Document