preview

Sonnet 43 By Elizabeth Barrett Browning

Good Essays

Within both poems, it is clear that both writers view the subject of love differently. Sonnet 43 by Elizabeth Barrett Browning is a love poem written in the form of a sonnet. It is about Browning’s intense love for her husband to be, Robert Browning.
The overall message of Valentine is how Duffy challenges society’s cliche ideas of love and Valentine’s Day and that one must experience being in a relationship to realise that society has greatly sold us into thinking that the cliche ideas of love such as roses or a satin heart that people give on valentines day is the presentation of love.

One of the main differences between the the two poems is the language used. In Sonnet 43 the language has rhythm and rhyme because of its sonnet structure. …show more content…

You can feel the onion is dangerous because it will “blind you with tears”. This gives the impression that this is what Duffy will do to her lover. As its a simile, it seems quite dangerous. Furthermore Duffy’s idea of love can be dangerous because when she kisses, its a “fierce kiss”. Fierce because of the powerful smell of onion, representing emotions in love. Perhaps Duffy does view love as dangerous because she finishes the poem with the word “knife”. In Duffy’s view this is perhaps a good thing. Duffy tells us that one must be “careful undressing love” because certainly there are risks involved. So in order to benefit from love, her lover must be careful just like with the …show more content…

We see both poets use metaphors to convey their ideas on love. In Valentine the onion is an extended metaphor where as Sonnet 43 Browning describes her love using a spatial metaphor where her love extends to the "depth" and "breadth" and "height" that her soul can "reach." Here Browning makes us think of love as a three-dimensional reality filling her soul. Valentine shows us how the unromantic characteristics of an onion fit the notions of love. In stanza 3, we see the negative sides of love through similes and metaphors. “Here. It will blind you with tears like a lover.” Duffy rejects the cliche ideas about love, by giving her lover an onion as a present for Valentines Day. The opposite of the “not a cute card or a kissogram.” Its quite unusual for Duffy to do this, because when we think of an onion we tend to relate an onion to something that makes us tearful and has a general bad taste. "It is a moon wrapped in brown paper” makes us think, how could an onion be a

Get Access