preview

Species Boundaries

Decent Essays

Within the study of evolution, the concept of a species and the mechanisms that create and maintain species boundaries are very important. In order to understand the fossil record and how a species can split into two or more separate species, researches must first define what they consider a species to be. There are two main competing theories about species, the biological species concept (BSC) and the ecological species concept (ESC). The biological species concept states that gene flow is the key to keeping groups cohesive and isolated. A species is considered to be a group of interbreeding organisms that are reproductively isolated from other groups of organisms. Therefore, members of each distinct group cannot mate successfully with other groups. Gene flow is what …show more content…

Also, some species remain the same with out gene flow between groups (Boyd and Silk 2000:97-99, Ridley 1993:393).
Natural selection acts as reinforcement to prevent dissimilar groups from producing hybrid species. Since hybrids are less fit, selection favors behavioral and morphological adaptations that prevent mating between groups. Reinforcement acts to reduce gene flow between groups in order to reduce the number of unfit offspring which reproductively isolates species to the point where they cannot interbreed at all. In the case of mules, who are hybrids of horses and donkeys, they are not less capable of competition with other animals, but they are less fit because they are unable to reproduce and get their genes into the next generation (Boyd and
Silk 2000:103, Ridley 1993:394).
In actuality, these two species concepts are not very distinct and neither is more valid or useful. Both theories can explain the mechanisms that cause different species to arise and remain distinct. If populations are not being selected upon, then gene flow is the mechanism keeping them separate. If selection is very strong, then it is probably the factor that is isolating

Get Access