3690 WordsApr 3, 201115 Pages

Journal of Counseling Psychology 1983, Vol. 30, No, 3,459-463
Copyright 1983 by the American Psychological Association, Inc.
Statistical Significance, Power, and Effect Size: A Response to the Reexamination of Reviewer Bias
Bruce E. Wampold
Department of Educational Psychology University of Utah
Michael J. Furlong and Donald R. Atkinson
Graduate School of Education University of California, Santa Barbara
In responding to our study of the influence that statistical significance has on reviewers ' recommendations for the acceptance or rejection of a manuscript for publication (Atkinson, Furlong, & Wampold, 1982), Fagley and McKinney (1983) argue that reviewers were justified in rejecting the bogus study when nonsignificant*…show more content…*

To detect a small experimental effect in the bogus study, for example, we would have had to increase the sample size from 81 to 1,206, or 134 subjects
459
460
COMMENTS argument is that because the average effect size for published research was equivalent to that of a medium effect, the reviewer 's decision to reject the bogus manuscript under the nonsignificant condition was "reasonable." Further examination of the Haase et al. (1982) article and our own analysis of published research, however, demonstrates that the power of the bogus study was great enough to detect effect sizes that are typical of research published in JCP, which was our intention when we designed the bogus study. First, although the median effect size (if) for all univariate statistical tests, significant and nonsignificant, reported by Haase et al. (1982) was .083, this index was steadily increasing at a rate of approximately .5% per year, so that the projected median if- in 1981 (the year our study was completed) would be .13. Importantly, an r)2 of .13 corresponds to an effect size (/) of .39, which Cohen (1977) designates as a large effect. A further examination of the Haase et al. (1982) data also lends support to our argument. Their analysis examined the strength of association for 11,044 univariate statistical tests derived from only 701 manuscripts; thus, each manuscript reported an average of more than 15 statistical tests. Since statistically significant and

Related

## Literature Review Breastfeeding Education

2390 Words | 10 Pagesgroup) Dependent Variable(s) Breastfeeding knowledge, attitude, satisfaction, problems, and rate of exclusive breastfeeding Statistical Tests Student’s t-test and chi-squared test were used to analyze differences between the two groups. Statistical Product and Service Solutions for Windows (SPSS) 12.0 software package and SAS 8.0 software. SPSS 12.0 was used for all statistical analysis except linear regression which used SAS 8.0. Article #2 Component Appraisal Comments Author & Publication Year

## Teaching Methods and Student Achievent

2000 Words | 8 Pagesparticipants in the study made up three groups whose academic achievement would be measured by an assessment at the end of lesson. The assessment used at the end of the lesson would serve as the posttest to which teaching method would have any significance in achievement scores. The experimental design was chosen due to the availability of students to the researcher. Procedure Teacher1 used the teaching method of Explicit Direct Instruction, which entails a series of steps that the teacher does

## An Analysis of Predictive Validity at Colleges Essay

2561 Words | 11 Pagescoursework and studying, thus presenting the possibility of negatively impacting a student’s grades and prolonging the length of time he or she stays at the institution? The purpose of this study is to investigate predictive validity and other statistical associations between the NSSE instrument and two commonly regarded student outcomes measures: time to graduation and grade point average (GPA). The objective is to establish an empirical link (whether positive or negative) between NSSE, with its

## Hygiene Among Different Religions Essay

611 Words | 3 PagesIn our study, there is a statistical significance between religion and practice of personal hygiene (P value is 0.025). The students belonging to Christian religion (40.70%) were following good practice of personal hygiene as compared to other two religion 21.00% (Hindu) and 31.70% (Muslim) respectively (Table no.11). There is no such comparison in other available studies. In our study, 100% of children were washing their hands before taking food. Maximum of 92.5% of students

## Discussion About Statistical Analysis and Results Essay

1341 Words | 6 PagesDISCUSSION ABOUT STATISTICAL ANALYSIS AND RESULTS; Statistical analysis two independent sample tests compare the mean of the randomised case-control group. To find the significant difference between the two groups, data collections are mean value, so t test is the suitable test to compare the mean value of the two groups in normal distributed data (Menz, 2004). Result of the t test shows body mass index significant p value .005 less than .05 and the mean value of the BMI in case group greater than

## Testing the Difference Between the Respondents Demographic Groups

956 Words | 4 Pagesstudy used the factor scores (which are not ordinal or nominal scales) yielded by the factor analysis for the further statistical analysis. Therefore, the parametric tests could be proper techniques to test the difference between the respondents’ demographic groups regarding the SECI and innovation activities in the Egyptian banks. In this term, there are two parametric statistical techniques to compare the difference means of the unpaired groups. The independent t-test is used to test whether two

## Statistical Control

2291 Words | 10 PagesSTATISTICAL CONTROL OF HOT SHOT PLASTIC KEYCHAINS TBD Webster University BUSN6110, Operation and Project Management [ 2/1/2015 ] Abstract This term paper examines a case study with Hot Shot Plastics company in which statistical process control (SPC) with variable measurements using X bar and R control charts is used to determine whether the process variability is in control. Sample data are utilized to demonstrate how to use X bar and R control charts to check if all the sample points

## ANSWER TO MODULE 5 ASSIGNMENT Essay

1963 Words | 8 Pagesthis output. Each factor and each covariate has a main effect, as does the intercept. Here these things are tested by four tests. Hotel ling’s Trace is commonly used for two dependent groups and Wilks' Lambda if there are more than two groups. The significance of the F tests show if that effect is significant as the P-value is less than .05 in this case. 6 What is the outcome of the multivariate tests (which looks at the effects of the IV on all three DVs at the same time)? Given results of your tests

## Testing Statistical Significance

1208 Words | 5 PagesTesting statistical significance is an excellent way to identify probably relevance between a total data set mean/sigma and a smaller sample data set mean/sigma, otherwise known as a population mean/sigma and sample data set mean/sigma. This classification of testing is also very useful in proving probable relevance between data samples. Although testing statistical significance is not a 100% fool proof, if testing to the 95% probability on two data sets the statistical probability is .25% chance

## Effects of Probiotic Youghurt and Cheese on Blood Lipids

3633 Words | 14 Pagesin total serum cholesterol during the intervention period, which supports those of Khedkar et al [28], a target sample of 180 persons (60 per group) was calculated. This estimation also provided a study power of 80% with SD of 28.0, a 2-sided 5% significance level and allowance of 20% loss in the follow ups. Randomization and blinding A 1:1:1 allocation ratio was considered to assign qualified participants into each group. Moreover, stratified blocked randomization was used by considering age, sex

### Literature Review Breastfeeding Education

2390 Words | 10 Pages### Teaching Methods and Student Achievent

2000 Words | 8 Pages### An Analysis of Predictive Validity at Colleges Essay

2561 Words | 11 Pages### Hygiene Among Different Religions Essay

611 Words | 3 Pages### Discussion About Statistical Analysis and Results Essay

1341 Words | 6 Pages### Testing the Difference Between the Respondents Demographic Groups

956 Words | 4 Pages### Statistical Control

2291 Words | 10 Pages### ANSWER TO MODULE 5 ASSIGNMENT Essay

1963 Words | 8 Pages### Testing Statistical Significance

1208 Words | 5 Pages### Effects of Probiotic Youghurt and Cheese on Blood Lipids

3633 Words | 14 Pages