3690 Words15 Pages

Journal of Counseling Psychology 1983, Vol. 30, No, 3,459-463
Copyright 1983 by the American Psychological Association, Inc.
Statistical Significance, Power, and Effect Size: A Response to the Reexamination of Reviewer Bias
Bruce E. Wampold
Department of Educational Psychology University of Utah
Michael J. Furlong and Donald R. Atkinson
Graduate School of Education University of California, Santa Barbara
In responding to our study of the influence that statistical significance has on reviewers ' recommendations for the acceptance or rejection of a manuscript for publication (Atkinson, Furlong, & Wampold, 1982), Fagley and McKinney (1983) argue that reviewers were justified in rejecting the bogus study when nonsignificant*…show more content…*

To detect a small experimental effect in the bogus study, for example, we would have had to increase the sample size from 81 to 1,206, or 134 subjects 459 460 COMMENTS argument is that because the average effect size for published research was equivalent to that of a medium effect, the reviewer 's decision to reject the bogus manuscript under the nonsignificant condition was "reasonable." Further examination of the Haase et al. (1982) article and our own analysis of published research, however, demonstrates that the power of the bogus study was great enough to detect effect sizes that are typical of research published in JCP, which was our intention when we designed the bogus study. First, although the median effect size (if) for all univariate statistical tests, significant and nonsignificant, reported by Haase et al. (1982) was .083, this index was steadily increasing at a rate of approximately .5% per year, so that the projected median if- in 1981 (the year our study was completed) would be .13. Importantly, an r)2 of .13 corresponds to an effect size (/) of .39, which Cohen (1977) designates as a large effect. A further examination of the Haase et al. (1982) data also lends support to our argument. Their analysis examined the strength of association for 11,044 univariate statistical tests derived from only 701 manuscripts; thus, each manuscript reported an average of more than 15 statistical tests. Since statistically significant and

To detect a small experimental effect in the bogus study, for example, we would have had to increase the sample size from 81 to 1,206, or 134 subjects 459 460 COMMENTS argument is that because the average effect size for published research was equivalent to that of a medium effect, the reviewer 's decision to reject the bogus manuscript under the nonsignificant condition was "reasonable." Further examination of the Haase et al. (1982) article and our own analysis of published research, however, demonstrates that the power of the bogus study was great enough to detect effect sizes that are typical of research published in JCP, which was our intention when we designed the bogus study. First, although the median effect size (if) for all univariate statistical tests, significant and nonsignificant, reported by Haase et al. (1982) was .083, this index was steadily increasing at a rate of approximately .5% per year, so that the projected median if- in 1981 (the year our study was completed) would be .13. Importantly, an r)2 of .13 corresponds to an effect size (/) of .39, which Cohen (1977) designates as a large effect. A further examination of the Haase et al. (1982) data also lends support to our argument. Their analysis examined the strength of association for 11,044 univariate statistical tests derived from only 701 manuscripts; thus, each manuscript reported an average of more than 15 statistical tests. Since statistically significant and

Related

## The Ongoing Tyranny Of Statistical Significance Testing

1066 Words | 5 Pagesongoing tyranny of statistical significance testing in biomedical research” describe common misuses and interpretation of statistical significance testing (SST). The authors point out fallacy understanding in interpretive the p-value and how it often mixed in measuring effect size and its precision. This misconception then they assert may impede scientific progress and furthermore become unintended harmful treatment. They also proposed an important way out of the significance fallacies in this article

## Testing Statistical Significance

1208 Words | 5 PagesTesting statistical significance is an excellent way to identify probably relevance between a total data set mean/sigma and a smaller sample data set mean/sigma, otherwise known as a population mean/sigma and sample data set mean/sigma. This classification of testing is also very useful in proving probable relevance between data samples. Although testing statistical significance is not a 100% fool proof, if testing to the 95% probability on two data sets the statistical probability is .25% chance

## Preliminary Bias And The Wason 2-4-6 Paradigm

1221 Words | 5 Pagestrying to confirm their beliefs during an experiment. During these experiments, participants results varied between confirmatory and disconfirmatory. The Tukey HSD that was performed for the experiments showed some significance in certain areas. For instance, there was a statistical significance for the total number of guesses between rule one and rule three. More simply, in the first experiment the results showed participants used confirmatory method more for rule one than rule three. For the second experiment

## Evaluation Of Statistics And Error Bars Essay

826 Words | 4 PagesProtect Lipid Membranes from Disruption by Aβ42” Presenting quantities in a research study requires use of statistical methods. Use of statistics help to determine the trend in the studies population. Statistical methods also help to interpret and compare research data and determine significance of the findings. Due to variety of statistical methods, it is crucial to adopt an appropriate statistical approach before the conducting the experiments. Furthermore, the representation of individual data points

## Evaluation Critique : Electoral Gender Quotas And Attitudes Toward Traditional Leaders

1339 Words | 6 PagesEvaluation Critique Article: “Electoral Gender Quotas and Attitudes Toward Traditional Leaders: A Policy Experiment in Lesotho” Authored By Amanda Clayton Annabel Osburn V562 10/29/14 Introduction and Background More than 100 countries have instituted gender quota policies in local governmental structures to increase representation by women in domestic politics. Research on the effect of these quotas on the number of women in office is robust, but study into the translation

## The Logistic Regression Model Was Used For Determine Fall Rates During A Hospitalization Essay

752 Words | 4 Pagesthe results of the statistical analysis, there is no clinical significance of adapting and translating SNRI into clinical practice to reduce the risk and incident of patient falls. All three hypothesis were not supported through the results of this study. While there was some change noted with the first hypothesis, it is not significant to support a change to clinical practice. A type II statistical error occurred in this instance because the study stated that there was significance with hypothesis

## Women's Experience Mortgage Credit

1225 Words | 5 Pagesother studies, Woodstock Institute [10] and Cyr [11]. Dietrich and Johannsson [15] study used a multivariate model, which control for economic factors considered during the underwriting decision. They found 15 of 18 fair lending exams had no statistical gender effect on the decision to deny a mortgage. The Robinson [9] study found that applications for low-income women were more likely to be originated than men of similar income. Awoonor-Williams [14] found that being a female statistically did

## Correlation Between Efficacy And Efficacy Of Vascular Complications

1041 Words | 5 PagesRecently, several studies reported that SP TFESI is a safer alternative to the conventional SA approach, because of the risk of vascular complications [20]. This study aimed to investigate the contrast spreading pattern and its correlation with efficacy for SP TFESI. Contrast was examined for the spread to both the ventral and dorsal epidural spaces, and in cephalic and caudal directions. Clinical efficacy was significantly correlated with the cephalic spreading pattern. These results indicate that

## Statistical Methods Using The Paired T Test And The Wilcoxon Matched Pairs

1661 Words | 7 PagesStatistical Methods in Healthcare Assignment #7 15 points Answer the following questions in narrative format: 1. Discuss when it is appropriate to use the paired t-test and the Wilcoxon matched-pairs signed-rank test. (2 points) The paired t-test is a parameter test that compares the means between two correlated pair groups. The paired t-test is used when two measures of the same interest are taken on the same participant at two different points in time. This participant is serving as

## The Impact Of Technology On Technology Acceptance

1154 Words | 5 PagesIntroduction A range of studies has been conducted on instructional technology. Many findings show that technology has a significant contribution to the improvement in teachers’ competency and instruction effectiveness. However, not all applications of technology in the classroom lead to the desired goals. There are numerous constrains that may contribute to this. The level of technology acceptance is one of these factors. However, what influences technology acceptance among teachers? The article

### The Ongoing Tyranny Of Statistical Significance Testing

1066 Words | 5 Pages### Testing Statistical Significance

1208 Words | 5 Pages### Preliminary Bias And The Wason 2-4-6 Paradigm

1221 Words | 5 Pages### Evaluation Of Statistics And Error Bars Essay

826 Words | 4 Pages### Evaluation Critique : Electoral Gender Quotas And Attitudes Toward Traditional Leaders

1339 Words | 6 Pages### The Logistic Regression Model Was Used For Determine Fall Rates During A Hospitalization Essay

752 Words | 4 Pages### Women's Experience Mortgage Credit

1225 Words | 5 Pages### Correlation Between Efficacy And Efficacy Of Vascular Complications

1041 Words | 5 Pages### Statistical Methods Using The Paired T Test And The Wilcoxon Matched Pairs

1661 Words | 7 Pages### The Impact Of Technology On Technology Acceptance

1154 Words | 5 Pages