preview

Stereotypes Vs Women

Decent Essays

Are men known scientifically to be funnier than women or is it just another stereotype? In the popular press article the authors, Peter McGraw and Joel Warner, show evidence to explain why people may think men are funnier than women. The authors first talk about how comedians are usually guys all over the world from Manhattan to Tokyo, men are more likely to create funnier cartoons, stand-up comedy is traditionally a male-dominated field, and men’s online dating profiles are comedic. The article then rebuttals that argument by explaining in McGraw’s class his students had a joke writing competition and based on a survey the men won, but only to a small degree. The authors explain men’s jokes are offensive and distasteful and the highest rated joke was written by a woman, thus woman are funnier according the authors (McGraw). In the academic article, a group of researchers implemented two experiments to test the theory that men are funnier than women. The first experiment was to get 32 participants to create captions for 20 cartoons and the participants were half women and half men. There were a group of 81 undergraduates that rated the captions of the cartoons, saying if they thought they were …show more content…

There were no specifics about any of the experiments and surveys stated to determine their credibility. There was nothing about sample size, diversity, nor procedures. However, McGraw and Warner did show diversity in saying that male comedians are from all over the world not just a specific area. They also state in the 2011 research there was a sample size of 250, and they stated their claim clearly at the end of the article (McGraw). The academic article changed my willingness to support the findings. However, I didn’t change my willingness to support the popular press article because it claimed a different statement and didn’t show supporting

Get Access