preview

Subsidized Health Care Cons

Decent Essays

The implementation of ACA requires the government to force insurance providers to give everyone health insurance regardless of what the insurance providers may want. This is very problematic in the context of the nation of USA since here corporations are treated as people and therefore, should have the same rights of personal liberty as people theoretically. Before the implementation of the ACA, the insurance agencies could turn away people that the insurance agencies deemed to be unreliable clients. Proponents of ACA argues from a deontological perspective that it is inhumane to allow corporations to turn away people who are dire need of medical help. Others consider this action by the government to be a slippery slope that can lead the way …show more content…

To make health care affordable for everybody, the Affordable Care Act subsidizes health care for low income families. This has been one of the controversial parts of the Affordable Care Act. There are many arguments for and against subsidized health care. The deontological argument for this subsidization is that we have a duty to help our fellow human beings in need. On the other hand, many argue with utilitarian logic that subsidized health care will have negative effect on the economy in the long run thus, ultimately, becoming an immoral act. …show more content…

Consequentialism only requires that the action that is being taken will ultimately increase the happiness of people. So a consequentialist argument based on the fact that if everyone in America had health insurance that would mean everyone in America has better physical and financial security. Thus, forcing everyone to have health insurance will directly cause the happiness of everyone to increase. Therefore, mandatory health insurance is not an immoral policy to implement from a consequentialist perspective. But, this may not apply to all aspects of ACA as ACA has many other policies which can be shown to have negative impact on people’s economic wellbeing.

Get Access