Secondary Source Work Erin McGlothin's essay, "Narrative Closure and the ‘Whew’ Effect: The Ethics of Reading Narratives of Survival of the Holocaust," provides a nuanced exploration of the ethical complexities inherent in engaging with Holocaust survivor memoirs. Central to McGlothin's argument is the concept of the "whew effect," a term she introduces to describe readers' immediate relief upon encountering moments of liberation or escape within these narratives. While this emotional response may offer a sense of catharsis, McGlothin contends that it often leads to an oversimplified understanding of the survivor's experience, obscuring the broader context of suffering, loss, and ongoing trauma. This "whew effect," according to McGlothin, is closely tied to the conventions and …show more content…
However, McGlothin warns that it can inadvertently reinforce readers' desire for tidy resolutions, thereby neglecting the deeper complexities and ethical challenges inherent in these narratives. In my exploration of narrative closure within Holocaust literature, McGlothin's concept of the "whew effect" resonates profoundly with my own observations and class discussions. This transformative moment in a survivor's narrative, which recalibrates a reader's emotional engagement and expectations, serves as a pivotal point that can either illuminate or obscure the multifaceted nature of the survivor's experience. However, what struck me most deeply in McGlothlin's analysis is the acknowledgment of the survivors' ambiguous relationship with this "whew" moment. Unlike readers, survivors themselves often do not experience this neat closure in their lived experiences. The journey from victimhood to survival is far more complex and fraught with uncertainties, lingering traumas, and painful memories that cannot be neatly encapsulated in a single liberating
“The Shawl” by Cynthia Ozick is short story in which a mother, her child, and her niece are described as they walk through a concentration camp during the Holocaust. This work is well known for its prominent use of figurative language. For a story about the Holocaust, it may seem odd as to why this language was used instead of a factual style of writing which is common in these types of stories. Ozick uses figurative language excessively in attempt to describe such a horrific situation. Some may criticize the author and even take offense to the way the story was written, but it does not have the same effect when told differently. Most accounts of the Holocaust are hard to comprehend, even for those who experienced it themselves. Ozick stated in an interview that even if everyone “were to spend the next five thousand years absorbing and assimilating the documents, it still
In this excerpt, it is like Jeannette and Rex are sitting in the wreckage after a storm. It’s as if they are having a final moment of clarity about the life Rex gave her. It’s interesting to see them finally interact with all their cards on the table, they aren’t playing any games anymore, they aren’t entertaining any of their far out ideas of their Glass Castle, they are simply being honest and direct and saying their last goodbyes, acknowledging things they never had before. When Jeannette says, “This stuff could grow on you.” in regards to the vodka and Rex answers, “Don’t let it.” Rex is acknowledging a large factor in the messed up life that his children had was because of his drinking and how his drinking ruined a lot of good prospects and opportunities the family could have had.
To conclude, Hedi Solzbach informs the reader of the tragedy of the Holocaust through personal experience. World War II was a scary and vicious time for many, but more specifically
The Holocaust is one of the most darkened events in human history, as it serves as a horrible event that took place 80 years ago. It stands as a chilling reminder of unchecked bigotry and intolerance of humans across the years and how a supreme leader can influence hatred in the souls of others. In the book ‘Night’, Eliezer Wiesel endured physical and mental pain while he was living in the camp. He was treated inhumanely like the rest of the inmates in Auschwitz who had lived there for years. This event shattered families across the nation, leaving permanent scars for generations to come, Elie was one of the millions of people who were affected by this event, and he bravely shared his memoir of some of the horrifying instances that he endured
Elie Wiesel’s nonfiction novel Night shares the author’s experience in Auschwitz which demonstrates the importance of memoirs. Throughout the novel, Elie’s experiences in the camp are narrated allowing readers to see into the young boy’s life. Seeing into the life of Elie enables readers to empathize for the young boy when he or his father is mistreated. By writing a nonfiction, readers are more likely to empathize with the main character since that individual exists. When readers are able to empathize with certain characters, the novel becomes more significant. Relating to Elie helps readers recognize the Holocaust in a different way. Instead of just learning about the event, readers are able to empathize with those who have suffered. Additionally,
Maxie Jones has been missing from the General Hospital canvas for months now. Back in February Kirsten Storms decided to take a leave of absence from her role and work out some personal issues. Rumors swirled around her gaunt appearance and lack of presence on social media. Storms was once incredibly interactive with her fans and she seemingly just vanished for weeks. It was speculated that her medical condition may have been affecting her, but no official word has been given about what caused her to leave General Hospital.
The lucid evidence of the physical and mental toll the camps took on the Jewish prisoner population successfully reinforces compassion, along with sympathy, within his readers for the situations the Jewish people in Germany had to face
The Holocaust can be described by facts, pictures, history lessons, among others, that can make a strong and lasting impression on an individual. However, testimonies are when the true horrors of this event become real. Testimonies are personal. Their authentic emotions, thoughts, and feelings are wrapped up in a little box with a red bow and given to the public as a fragile gift. Survivor Manya Friedman wrote, “I had little confidence when I started. My hands were so shaky I could barely read my own writing. As I started writing, I was given confidence, support, and encouragement. If I can do this, then you can too” (“The Transition”). Due to her strength and many others, individuals who weren’t affected by the holocaust are fortunate to be provided with such thoughtful insight about how the lives of these Jewish individuals were affected and remain affected. Even so, their experiences are something we will never be able to fathom.
The topic of the Holocaust is a broad and gruesome one; maybe it is because of the horrors that happened that people still write about it, to try to understand what happened, and how it did. Regardless, Elie Wiesel explains why he, as a Holocaust survivor, writes within his essay “Why I Write: Making No Become Yes”. He writes that perhaps it is “…in order not to go mad.” or “to touch the bottom of madness.” These two possible reasons are quite different from each other, yet they share a similar topic, this is similarly true about Elie Wiesel’s essay and Harry Weinberg’s short story “A Letter to Harvey Milk” The similarities and differences in these two works shows the varying ways people cope with similar past experience, the impact those memories can have on their lives, and the effect sharing those experiences can have on them.
When learning about the Holocaust, most are deprived of being able to understand the emotions, thoughts, and experiences of the millions of Jews; however, Elie Wiesel gives this opportunity through the telling of his personal experience. After ten years of silence, Elie Wiesel recounts his personal experiences of the Holocaust and retells the horrific details of the events he witnessed in his honest, eye-opening memoir Night. Taken at a young age, Elie Wiesel is transported to Auschwitz; at this concentration camp, Wiesel is separated from his mother and younger sister, whom he would never see again. During his years in the concentration camp, Wiesel and his father worked long exhausting hours every day. After a forty-two mile trip from Auschwitz to Gleiwitz in the snow and bitter cold, Elie Wiesel watches the slow death of his father by malnutrition and a harsh beating from the Nazis. Three months later American forces liberate the camp, freeing Wiesel. One of the most important memoirs one can read and a true inspiration, Night deserves to be read by everyone.
The authors imply the truth about the Holocaust through textual evidence influencing enlightenment. This story is intended for the general public since the authors goals was to expose the unfiltered truth of Nazi Germany and World War II. Throughout the book the authors reflected sources from experiences they had to
Weisel says that any survivor who has told the story of their experiences in the Holocaust cannot tell the whole story, or people will think that they are crazy. "Most novelists of this category, or most writers, seem to have followed the same pattern. Viewing literature as a way to correct their friends, to their families, to their own childhood and to their people (Weisel 8)."
In the aftermath of the Jewish Holocaust, an outpouring of eyewitness accounts by both survivors and perpetrators has surfaced as historical evidence. For many, this has determined what modern popular culture remembers about this atrocious event. Emotion obviously plays a vital role in the accounts of the survivors, yet can it be considered when discussing the historical significance of the murder of six million European Jews by the Third Reich? Emotion is the expression of thoughts and beliefs affected by feeling and sensibility of an individual regarding a certain event or individual. In terms of the Holocaust, emotion is overwhelmingly prevalent in the survivors’ tales of their experiences, conveyed in terms of life, death, and
Generally, I had a positive outlook toward life in junior high and high school. I had great friends, teachers, parents, and teammates that supported my life goals and decisions. I thoroughly enjoyed my hobbies and practice to get my mind off of school. When it comes to Marcia’s identity statuses, I would say that I was in between identity foreclosure and moratorium. In junior high school, I basically participated in the activities and life choices that my parents and family thought were best, so I would consider my status to be foreclosure. If my parents wanted me to contribute to specific organizations, then I would because I did not want to upset their thoughts and opinions. In high school, I began to research and look into my own career choices, so I feel that I was in the very beginning stage of
Everyone experiences emotional and physiological obstacles in their life. However, these obstacles are incomparable to the magnitude of the obstacles the prisoners of the Holocaust faced every day. In his memoir, Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel, illustrates the horrors of the concentration camps and their mental tool. Over the course of Night, Wiesel demonstrates, that exposure to an uncaring, hostile world leads to destruction of faith and identity.