preview

Summary Of Erin Mcglothin's Narrative Foreclosure

Decent Essays
Open Document

Secondary Source Work Erin McGlothin's essay, "Narrative Closure and the ‘Whew’ Effect: The Ethics of Reading Narratives of Survival of the Holocaust," provides a nuanced exploration of the ethical complexities inherent in engaging with Holocaust survivor memoirs. Central to McGlothin's argument is the concept of the "whew effect," a term she introduces to describe readers' immediate relief upon encountering moments of liberation or escape within these narratives. While this emotional response may offer a sense of catharsis, McGlothin contends that it often leads to an oversimplified understanding of the survivor's experience, obscuring the broader context of suffering, loss, and ongoing trauma. This "whew effect," according to McGlothin, is closely tied to the conventions and …show more content…

However, McGlothin warns that it can inadvertently reinforce readers' desire for tidy resolutions, thereby neglecting the deeper complexities and ethical challenges inherent in these narratives. In my exploration of narrative closure within Holocaust literature, McGlothin's concept of the "whew effect" resonates profoundly with my own observations and class discussions. This transformative moment in a survivor's narrative, which recalibrates a reader's emotional engagement and expectations, serves as a pivotal point that can either illuminate or obscure the multifaceted nature of the survivor's experience. However, what struck me most deeply in McGlothlin's analysis is the acknowledgment of the survivors' ambiguous relationship with this "whew" moment. Unlike readers, survivors themselves often do not experience this neat closure in their lived experiences. The journey from victimhood to survival is far more complex and fraught with uncertainties, lingering traumas, and painful memories that cannot be neatly encapsulated in a single liberating

Get Access