preview

Summary Of ' We Are Not Created Equal Through Every Way ``

Good Essays

In an article titled “We Are Not Created Equal in Every Way” that appeared in The San Francisco Chronicle on December 12 2000, reporter and columnist Joan Ryan expressed her opinion regarding the story of Fredrika Keefer. Miss Keefer was an 8-year-old whose mother, Krissy Keefer, sued the San Francisco Ballet School after Fredrika was refused admission to the school because of her body type. While Ryan’s article is an opinion piece, many of her arguments and comparisons are ill-thought-out, fallacious, or do not contribute much of anything to the piece.
Within the first few paragraphs Ryan says “Fredrika and her mother filed suit…” while possible discrimination against Fredrika may be the subject of the suit, Fredrika was an 8-year-old at …show more content…

Ryan goes on to say that Fredrika could still have a future in professional dance in a separate genre, failing to consider that the building blocks of most dance genres are based in ballet, and many teachers of other types of dance would still want their students taking ballet in addition to their classes. Another important factor is that Fredrika is a child and her body is going to change significantly as she gets older. Fredrika may not have the “ideal” body for ballet as an 8-year-old, but as she develops into an adult her body may fit the archetype that is sufficient for ballet. Furthermore, should Fredrika’s body, possibly, become the definitive ballet body, she would still require the training she is seeking to be able to compete as a professional.
At one point, Ryan asserts that thin bodies are the standard for classical ballet, therefore a ballet school choosing not accept applicants with a different body type is not discriminatory. Ryan goes on to express that she is troubled by the age at which children begin training for adult careers, another common practice in ballet. It is duplicitous of Ryan to cherry pick a certain standard of ballet in an effort bolster one part of her argument, and then critique another standard of ballet that isn’t in line with

Get Access