Taming Of The Shrew Comparison Essay

I will be studying the fight scene where Mercutio and Tybalt die, and comparing, the two film versions of the play, I will find differences and similarities as well as describing how each director / producer interprets and makes their version of the film. I will describe how eight different factors are present in each version of the film:

With any comparison between a play and its movie counterpart there are bound to be major differences and key similarities between

Another difference in the movie from the play is the obvious different points of view. The play is told from Estela’s point of view and the movie is shown through Ana’s point of view. The play shows more of Estela’s struggles in the factory, not being able to pay for the machines, paying rent and most being an undocumented worker in the

Katharina, also known as Kate, is the main protagonist and her fiery personality is the focal point of the Shakespeare play, “The Taming of the Shrew”. Her outspoken and quick-witted disposition is at odds with polite society thus earning her the offensive moniker ‘Shrew’, which essentially means a bad-tempered despicable old hag. Contrary to belief, she is, for the most part, an opinionated woman who has the courage to speak those opinions loudly to men that would prefer she’d be quiet. Throughout the play Kate’s demeanor evolves and shifts much like the incredible metamorphosis of a caterpillar turning into a butterfly; in this case a lovely socially acceptable butterfly. This essay will analyze Katharina’s performance throughout the play hence concluding that she is not befitting of the moniker Shrew.

One important difference found between the play and the movie is the time period. Caesar is the leader of Rome with a group of senators that are his servants while Regina is the leader of the high school Plastics which is a group of three girls: Regina, Gretchen, and Karen. Everybody in the high school loves and knows everything about the Plastics and the girls look up to them. Caesar gets killed by Brutus for the sake of the people of Rome and Regina’s life gets ruined for the sake of high school students, for revenge from Janis Ian, and so Cady can steal her boyfriend, Aaron

First the movie opening scene establishes a more cheerful mood, unlike what Shakespeare wrote in this scene, Beatrice is seen resting a poem and all the other settlers of Messina who accompany her are dancing and very happy. Shakespeare shows a comedy in a more conservative mood and present women in a role more respectful than the director of the film does . Another difference can be seen with the character of Dogberry who in the plays is shown as more idiotic than what it seen in the film. For example in the Act III scene 3 when he said “nay that were a punishment too good for them, if they should have any allegiance”with allegiance he means disloyalty ,and this dialogues ,as many others where he changed the meanings of words, are not in the movie .Other difference is that in the film from the beginning Hero is in love with Claudio,in the first scene they make an exchange of glances that cause us the impression that is not only Claudio who is attracted to her but she is too. In the play meanwhile when Claudio asked Benedick “Is she not a modest young lady?” It seems that they do not know each

William Shakespeare, a timeless author is responsible for making many different priceless pieces of art including, The Taming of a Shrew. The Taming of a Shrew was published by William Shakespeare in the year 1590, and has since become one of the most famous plays around the world. The Taming of a Shrew contains many different literary devices throughout the play to impact the audience and develop the plot. Like many of Shakespeare’s plays, comedy is one of the strong points in The Taming of a Shrew. Shakespeare uses many different comedic devices throughout the story to help develop the plot.

The Taming of the Shrew is a play Written by William Shakespeare between 1590 & 1592 But was Published in 1980. The play is based around Katerina the eldest daughter and Bianca the youngest, Lucentio a scholar, Petruchio Katerina’s husband and Katerina’s many suitors before Petruchio. Before Bianca is allowed near any boys Katerina must be married. 10 things I hate about you was adapted from Taming of the Shrew. The movie was in the same category as Taming of the shrew meaning that they used William Shakespeare’s script, but Kristen Smith and Karen McCullah edited it to make it more modern. The movie was released by touchstone pictures on the 31st of March 1999 in the USA. In this essay, the focus will be on comparing the similarities and differences of the play and film.

My first topic I will be talking about is time period. In this movie horses are replaced with mustang cars. Also, swords are switched to guns with the label of their house name on the gun. The Balcony scene is switched to a pool scene, which is totally different then the movie. The beginning scene with Sampson and Gregory is set up different, it shows Benvolio and the Montagues cruising in a yellow convertible and the gas station sets on fire from a

I found the movie to be an interesting version of the play not so much in the slight plot variations but in the staging and character portrayal. I think it was highly engaging for Zeffirelli to allow every other character to be colorful, jovial and light-hearted while Katerina was always shown as a darker, meaner, more dramatic personality. Elizabeth Taylor was always costumed in much more dramatic silhouettes and she continuously was the loudest character in any scene. There were several occasions where I turned down the volume on the movie only when Katerina entered the scene because Elizabeth Taylor took many liberties with Kate’s dramatic side. Between the yelling, the smashing of furniture and the chasing of other characters while threatening them with blunt objects, Kate’s character was intensely elevated beyond how one might read her to be in the play.

William Shakespeare, an internationally renowned playwright, wrote many texts that are still performed to this day. The Taming of the Shrew is no exception. Because of its popularity, the text was released as a film in 1967 and 1999. The original adaptation follows a similar storyline to the Shakespearean text. It incorporates the same values and ideologies of love depicted in the initial play created in 1590. 10 Things I Hate About You is somewhat of a modernized film version of the earlier text; it compliments more modern cultural values. Based on my beliefs and interpretations of both films, I have reached the conclusion that The Taming of the Shrew is an exercise of misogyny. This contradicts my perspective of the more recent film adaptation;

William Shakespeare’s Hamlet is a very famous play that well known among all types of entertainment. Its been made into many different movies and plays that have been viewed all around the world. In 1990 Franco Zeffirelli made the play into a studio movie. Although the movie is still called hamlet, there are still many major differences to the overall film and play. Characters, scenes, lines and language all contributed to the similarities and differences between the play and the movie. Although the director made many changes to the film, he did not change the story but he changed the viewer’s perspective on all the characters.

The actors played their role well through words and actions. The beautiful Bianca was “daddy’s favorite,” leaving Katharine to speak her mind. Petruchio, a man starving for wealth, showed his witty character along his adventure with Kate. He controlled her and became frustrated when she disobeyed him. In the Italian city of Padua, the story is performed to fit the time period and overall feel that Shakespeare creates in his plays. Although the language was difficult to understand, I was able to follow the plot and understand how the play was constructed to fit the time of which it was

10 things I hate about you presents itself as a modern day adaption of taming of the shrew. The direct application of plot, characters and tees such as gender, individualism and conformity, to a contemporary society emphasizes the timelessness and universality of the play. The play has been appropriated to a modern day setting to serve as a framework for the themes to be explored in a contemporary context. Taming of the Shrew is renowned as Shakespeare’s more boisterous comedy, but contrary to his other works, devotes a lot of attention to life after the wedding. The context to the play was based on the time it was shaped- that is, the renaissance. The English society was heavily concerned with marriage die to henry VIIIi’s separation from the catholic church in 1534. Consequently, the resolution of marital disputes were highlighted in the popular literature of the Elizabethan era. 10 things I hate about you has used Taming of the Shrew in order to present the themes in the original text to a modern audience in a context and form which relates to them.

‘The Taming of the Shrew’, is one of William Shakespeare’s most celebrated works in history and is known to be one of his most comedic pieces of literature. With its’ lighthearted sense of a late 1500’s Elizabethan era work, the famous play showed many relevant ideologies of society according to its particular era in history. Many of Shakespeare's works have been adapted into successful films that were made to suit the society of a new and different age, for example, his piece ‘The Taming of the Shrew’, has been formed into several films and short films. In my opinion, it just shows that Shakespeare's writings are still relevant today and forever will be timeless.