preview

The Clumsy One Conflict

Decent Essays
Open Document

Conflict in “The Clumsy One”

“Did you ever strike your brother?” In the beginning of the story, Danny Redmond the protagonist of Ernest Buckler’s “The Clumsy One,” asks this question, touching upon the main external conflict between Daniel and his brother, David (man vs. man). The conflict occurred on David’s “first summer home from college.” David went to college in the city, alone, since he was “clumsy with anything outside the shadow world of books, and it was David who had the magic sleight for anything that could be maneuvered with his hands.” Danny desperately tried to be successful on his family’s farm, but didn’t have the talent of working the land. After returning home to the farm, he was surprised by two men he knew from college, …show more content…

His friends “had the smooth city way of talking. David’s straight talk would have seemed stupid to them.” The group of men barely acknowledged David’s presence as he “hesitated alongside” them. “The others scarely glanced after him, thinking he was the hired man.” Danny excluded his own brother, proving it to him that “he wouldn’t fit in at all.” The close relationship between the brothers was strained between a sense of guilt and embarrassment. Danny was so distraught with his hurtful actions that he starts to dream, “making it happen a different way,” where his brother is shown the deepest request and admiration he deserved. Danny didn’t “strike” his brother angrily due to his insensitivity but because of the immaturity of sibling rivalry. “Sometimes there is a cruel persuasion you cant resist in the hurting of one who understands you best, even as it hurts you more.” He also remembered when his big brother would protect him “of any one the older ones (kids) so much as laid a finger on [him].” Even though David was hurt, he still protected his brother, albeit in an obscure manner. The following day, the men worked with the wood saw, “lifting the heavy logs and carrying them to the saw table.” The many times Danny worked with the saw, David “managed that I got a break in the work now and then, without drawing attention to my weakness.”

Get Access