preview

The Complex Alceste of Moliere's Misanthrope Essays

Better Essays

The Complex Alceste of The Misanthrope

"I cannot improve on it, and assuredly never shall," said Molière of his satire The Misanthrope, {1} and the critic Nicholas Boileau-Despréaux concurred by accounting it one of Molière's best plays.{2} But the French public did not like it much, preferring the dramatist's more farcical The Doctor in Spite of Himself--a play that, according to tradition, was written two months after The Misanthrope's premiere to make up for the latter's lack of success.{3} In fact, The Misanthrope horrified Rousseau, who thought that its aim was, in Donald Frame's words, "to make virtue ridiculous by pandering to the shallow and vicious tastes of the man of the world."{4} Both he and Goethe after him regarded …show more content…

Célimène is a manipulative coquette with a sarcastic tongue and a cold heart. Philinte seems a rather neutral character who, like Hamlet's Horatio, is "a piece of dramatic structure" thrown in simply to be Alceste's confidant. Éliante is even less defined, and her most notable speech, a somewhat flippant pronouncement about love,{8} is (in my opinion) alienating instead of endearing.

We must turn to Alceste, for he at least values honesty and sincerity. He truly wishes to rip off every hypocrite's mask, to force all men to stand accountable for what they really are. Although he asserts, "No, it is general; I hate all men,"{9} his stance is motivated by his rejection of the evil that they do, not any personal ill will. Since an audience likes to suppose itself on the side of virtue, it will naturally sympathize with a protagonist who opposes vice. In addition, as Frame points out,

". . . Molière endows Alceste with a magnetism that is his alone. Not only does Oronte seek to become his friend; he enjoys the devoted friendship of Philinte, and he is the man most loved by the three leading ladies of the play."{10}

But the fact remains that Alceste's zeal for the chastisement of society is adulterated by what Richard Wilbur calls "his vast, unconscious egotism."{11} Alceste has to lie to himself, to assure himself that the world is uniformly as bad as he makes it out to be. The faults of mankind, great as they are, become enormous when Alceste mentally

Get Access