Eggsploitation is a 2010 documentary that draws attention towards the multi-billion dollar infertility industry in the United States. The filmmaker does this by investigating what transpires within the egg donation business and interviewing donors who have had damaging effects since contributing. Ultimately they go as far as to compare the process to human trafficking because of some of the consequences of donating eggs alone. The film is incredibly thought provoking and brings up several critical points, most notably the lack of sufficient safety data on the risks of egg extraction or even donor post operation records documentation. However despite this the film remains exceedingly bias as it aggressively emphasizes its views on how women
“So many eggs that have the potential to become human beings, are being flushed down the toilet or soaked up in napkins every month,” said a wise older man from New Haven, Connecticut, “It disgusts me that so many babies are being killed every month. Imagine that your 26-year-old daughter has been getting her
Lastly, Mary, a co-worker, was interviewed in relation to embryonic harvesting and freezing. Mary’s nursing experience spans 30 years and as she states, science and technology have changed tremendously since the beginning of her career. Although she promotes the process of life, such as in the case of the Capato’s, she does state ethical concern in morality resulting when “embryonic freezing and harvesting is manipulated for the purposes of research,
Finally, the resolution of this topic is analyzed through a recorded interview and both printed and online articles. The resolution of this issue is society's take on IVF since the birth of Louise Joy Brown, and how this advancement has impacted the world. First analyzed is a recorded interview video from BBC, an international source. This interview is of Louise Brown as an adult, and helps portray the reality of this situation. The interview helps viewers understand that this artificial fertilization technique produced a real, living, breathing human being. She can formulate thoughts and opinions about the medical breakthrough that was her birth. This interview asks Louise what she feels her birth has brought to the world (Brown), but may
Deborah L. Spar’s book, The Baby Business, provides an eye opening experience about surrogacy and the selling of eggs without women becoming pregnant. I am surprised to know how people in general and the field of medicine in particular can and has find ways to make the process of procreation possible and a accessible through marketing. Considering the time of Abraham when Sara who longed to have a child asked her husband to give her a child through her maid and claim him/her as her own, was
“The methods used to obtain eggs have put egg donation in the spotlight, especially the issue of compensating women for their eggs.” (Chapter Preface)
In the 1998 article, “Egg head”, published by Human Life review, the author, Kathryn Jean Lopez stresses that many women, mostly in their twenties, that accommodate sterile couples to give birth by “donating” their eggs for money are not fully aware of the risk and harm that may occur after. In accordance, Lopez states that the women that undergo the procedure of the “donation” of their ovaries are usually women in their twenties or college girls. These are the most targeted type of groups of donators, for they are the believed to be the fittest contestant, and more than likely to produce more eggs. Additionally, she also explains that the “donation” consists of several tests, which involve ultra sounds; injections etc. The process of the “donation”
Technological and scientific advancement has introduced various changes in the reproduction process. For instance, women can undertake safe abortions, use birth control pills and freeze their eggs. The idea of freezing eggs has often been used to help women undergo cancer treatment techniques that are more likely to interfere with their fertility. Women with crippling genetic disorders have also used the freezing option so that they can offer their eggs to someone that is not a carrier of the same disorder. However, recently, healthy and fertile women tend to freeze their eggs with the claims of being busy and focusing with their careers. Hence, they decide to postpone conception and pregnancy for a later period. The behavior seems unethical because some of these women are simply persuaded by their organizations and they agree with the idea because they are afraid of being sacked. The lack of informed
“One need not be deeply religious or oppose abortion to be troubled by the prospect of a society in which, as bioethicist Alexander Capron puts it, ‘The wanted child becomes the made-to-order child’" (Shannon). With rising concerns of building a baby through eugenics and IVF or In Vitro Fertilization, the government, court systems, activists, and public media is starting to take notice. Being able to pick your babies’ generic make up would be an ethical disaster with a slippery slope into an era where one’s child is created by man with build-a-baby qualities instead of the natural creation of a new life. Creating a designer baby through IVF technology would have severe consequences not only affecting this generation by all the future
In the article “Eggs for Sale”, M.A. Garcia writes about her own experience regarding the sale of her eggs, and the sacrifices that involves. There are various ways in which a couple or an individual may go about conceiving a child Outside of the standard practices. The author writes about personal feelings, emotional and physical. These are things that I can in no way imagine. I can only sympathize with her or anyone that has to, or chooses to go through this kind of procedure. I can understand how polarizing the choices can be. Through the descriptive I can understand how painful the choices can be, but never truly understand. As a man, selling of uterine eggs is not one I ever thought of. Thus it is difficult for me to compartmentalize
Reproductive technologies are trying to be part of the norms in society. These movies show that woman can chose to do things that back then would be considered vulgar, including showing a pregnant lady half naked or being able to have a baby without a man. If one wants a baby, instead of adopting she can now have her own biological baby. Kelly Oliver lectured about it, in order to enlighten us about what is happening now in our society. Biomedical ethics would benefit from studying popular representations of reproductive technologies, because this is something that is flourishing; thus, needs our special attention.
The author’s experience of donating eggs to an infertile couple was life-changing to her point-of-view of new life and the reader’s knowledge of egg donation. At the end of her story, I started to agree the author’s perspective of giving her eggs to someone else. During the story, I noticed that she started to worry about the health of the unborn child and donating eggs takes a long process by checking her health and injecting many needles to her body. In addition, she does not want to let the couples down because they wanted a child of their own and cannot do it without her eggs. My personal belief about egg donation is almost the same as a child adoption. Beginning of the process is where the couples find the right egg donor like a perfect
Sahar JabaiahShould young women sell their eggs?In the article “should young women sell their eggs?'' By DONNA DE LA CRUZ, she talked about Ms. Justine Griffin and Mrs. Cool when they sold their eggs. Ms. Griffin was paid $5,000 and she only did it once, not for the money, but for the mother of a deceased childhood friend struggles to get pregnant after her daughter's death. Mrs. Cool was paid $7,000 for her eggs and she was in danger due to a developed hyper stimulation syndrome.I' m against women who are selling their eggs. After I read the article, the only thing comes to mind is chicken. Chicken lay eggs and people buy, women produce eggs and people buy. Why women want to sell their eggs? Students in college want to finish their education
Tsipy Ivry’s book on Israeli and Japanese pregnancy processes is an important work towards feminist anthropology and the study of pregnancy and birth in anthropology. The focuses of pregnancies brought to term in Israel and Japan, and the U.S. have many differences. The importance of genetic testing in the U.S. and Israel, and the lack of importance of it in Japan is very interesting and culturally-based. In an updated paper from 2011, Rayna Rapp expands on birthing practices and childbearing in New York City, in regards to genetic testing. Rapp also spread their studies into how western reproductive technology has spread to “developing nations” and the phenomena of wealthy westerners heading to less economically developed countries for IVF, stem cell, and other reproductive treatments and services. For example, embryotic tissue is regarded differently and more secularly in India than many Euro-American discourses and thus many seek medical treatment in India that are from other countries. The IVF process greatly effects marriages and depending upon its success further impacts partnerships and marriages, as well as gendered expectations of motherhood and fatherhood. Many women in rural countries, in good health, will donate their eggs too for monetary gain. Furthermore, IVF can be complicated by cultural and religious beliefs and practices. For example, in Israel traditional IVF is banned but obtaining eggs from other non-Jewish women is permitted, or in Sharia Iran, the
Artificial reproductive technology (ART) is defined as procedures which stimulate a woman 's ovaries to produce eggs, the eggs are then removed, combined with sperm, and then returned to a woman 's body (Bell, 2016). ART is becoming more and more popular throughout that globe. This method of conceiving children gives women who may be struggling with infertility options that were not possible before the advent of such methods. ART is relevant to the sociological definition of global health because it is evidence of the fact that our world has become interdependent especially when it comes to medical technology. However with ART comes the notion of the culture of disguise and in many countries this is an integral part of artificial reproductive technology process. With that being said, sociologists should look to study and understand the culture of disguise in ART as it pertains to global health and it shapes interactions between people and the society they live in.
Another reason some people argue that surrogacy is immoral or unethical is because it is perceived as demeaning to women with the possibility of exploitation. In 1992 ???????????????? justified intruding in the plaintiff’s right to procreate for three reasons, the third was because “surrogacy-for-profit arrangements have the potential for demeaning women by reducing them to the status of “breeding machines”” (Doe v.